• We've issued a clarification on our policy on AI-generated work.
  • Our mod selection process has completed. Please welcome our new moderators.
  • The regular administrative staff are taking a vacation, and in the meantime, Biigoh is taking over. See here for more information.
  • A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.
  • The rules regarding NSFW links have been updated. See here for details.

With This Ring (Young Justice SI) (Thread Fourteen)

Meetings Squared (part 2) New
13th February 2284
15:48 GMT -6


"Ah!" I nod as I fold up the briefing document some well-meaning Shady Sands spod who was probably unfamiliar with his audience wrote and pass it back to Balm. "Okay, I think I understand where they're coming from."

"It is from their capital."

"Sorry. I mean, metaphorically. Of all the tribes in our alliance, the New California Republic is the most powerful. But they're not as powerful as all of the rest put together, and they're going to be having difficulty occupying Arizona once the Legion collapses. So they want to arrange things so that the summit very obviously doesn't favour them too greatly."

Balm nods. "They wish to appear magnanimous, and so encourage us to accept their leadership."

"That's part of it, but it also… Makes sense. For the members of the Enclave tribe, it is part of their… Religion? That the United States didn't collapse at the end of the Great War, it just entered a period of turmoil."

"You told me that it had been two hundred years."

I nod. "A long period of turmoil. They all believe in it fervently. They're not always entirely sure what it is that they believe about it, but they're all faithful. So while you and I both know that you're the chief of the Ammonites, and therefore paramount chief of… What do you call the area you rule?"

"I would usually call them 'our lands'. Or I refer to the rivers which bound them."

"Paramount chief of this region, then. But they believe that this region is called Utah. And while they don't care if a people who call themselves Ammonites live here, under their law the chief of the Ammonites has no significance."

"Why should I care about their law in my lands?"

"You said that you would not insult someone else's god?" He nods. "This is their god, the nation that fought the Great War. They can be reasonable about many things, but not that."

"So I put on the war paint of the Governor of Utah, and that gives me standing in their law?"

"Yes. And it's a lot easier to understand for people further away, like Valentina Rosado, who apart from speaking to Tears for a few minutes has never met anyone from the Ammonites, or any other tribe in this region."

"She is-. Ah." He smiles. "One of my daughter's co-wives."

"No-. Please don't ever say that. I have met her husband-."

"The machine-" He stares. "-did not check that she was unwed?"

"She kept her maiden name, so I suspect that Doki just assumed that she wasn't married."

"Ah."

"Valentina is President of The Republic of the Rio Grande. But because Rio Grande was a state before the war, she'll be addressed as Governor during the conference, just as Grant will be referred to as the Governor of California."

"And… Am I the Governor, under their law?"

"Each of the states had their own rules on how governors were chosen. If the people of Utah have chosen you, that's enough. But… One of the things we'll be discussing is how governors should be chosen in the future."

"The governor of a state. Which need not be the same as the chief of the Ammonites."

"Yes."

"Hm." He nods. "And what of you?"

"The land of the Sky Walkers is part of the State of Nevada, but we don't really have a candidate, and… New Reno was effectively annexed by the N.C.R. after Doctor Anderson's forces ravaged it. Us sending a separate Governor wouldn't really make sense at the moment."

House doesn't want the job, none of the Wrights have a high enough profile -I mean, I don't blame them for running and hiding when Anderson stormed the city with Enclave power armour divisions, but it didn't exactly earn them acclaim-, Lynnette… Thinks of most of us as uncivilised savages, Vargas has a good reputation but he wants to move back to Arizona as soon as possible, and I… Haven't spent enough time working in this state, which isn't yet in any position to function as a state. Balm works because his tribe conquered Utah, while Grant works because the major cities in California voluntarily came together and backed him. Nevada's not there, nor anywhere near there.

"You will not attend?"

"No, I'll attend. And I'll be running around in the background. I just won't have a special title." I sigh. "I don't know. If it's really necessary I'll try and get Lynette to agree to Hernán Vargas being our 'Governor', but it would look… Silly."

"Do Grant Hayes and Augustus Autumn wish to return to life their god, the United States of America?"

"Augustus does. Grant could go either way, but… It's not a bad set up for administering a lot of territory, and the N.C.R. isn't very good at controlling territory away from its core cities."

"I have been able to use freed slaves and minor tribes to control the lands that were the property of the Eighties. Chief Thunderbird did something similar to take tribute from the weaker tribes he ruled. Why does Grant not do the same?"

"Well, in the example of the Mojave, the people weren't unified enough to join as a group, or enthusiastic enough about the N.C.R. to become citizens and govern their own affairs. When the N.C.R. conquered the Rapids and the Baja peninsular, they moved in large numbers of people who were already Californians in order to control the land. But between the Legion and the lack of water, no one really wanted to move into the Mojave so that wasn't an option."

He nods. He's uneducated, not stupid. "If the paramount chief of a state is called a Governor, what are the lesser chiefs called?"

"Mayors. Usually, a settlement of any size would have a mayor, though only the mayors of larger towns and cities would be considered important. Mayors report to the governor."

There's a faint smile on his lips, though I'm not sure-. "And who is above the governors?"

"Strictly speaking, no one. The Governor is the highest government authority where matters pertaining to their own state are concerned. They usually work within a framework of laws, and if they go against those laws there are people who have the power to refuse them-" He nods. Balm isn't an absolutist. He's used to having elders he needs to explain himself to. "-but that's within the laws of the state. The United States of America had a Supreme Chief who held the title President-."

"Ah. That is why the Presidents are calling themselves Governors."

"Probably. Otherwise, it would get confusing."

"And what does this Supreme President do?"

"Deals with things outside of the United States of America, deals with problems between states, and controls the military of the whole of the country. That's the… Simple version. The full version is a good deal more complex. Presidents tended to try to centralise power to themselves at the expense of the governors… But even if our alliance becomes more like the United States of America I suspect that the office will be far more limited."

He frowns. "Governors do not have soldiers?"

"Not exactly. They have armed police for fighting raiders and criminals, and they have a militia called the National Guard, but most of the military was controlled by the President."

"We do not have a President. Does Grant want to take that title?"

"I don't think he'd mind getting it, but we're not unified enough for anyone to accept someone having that degree of power over them."

He nods. "Good."

"And we couldn't perform the proper ritual for choosing a President anyway. Not until all of the lands of the United States are allied to us. No, at this stage we're just reorganising allied states and working out how best to support one another."

He nods slowly. "Then that is something that I can do."
 
Last edited:
13th February 2284
15:48 GMT -6


"Ah!" I nod as I fold up the briefing document some well-meaning Shady Sands spod who was probably unfamiliar with his audience and pass it back to Balm. "Okay, I think I understand where they're coming from."

"It is from their capital."
Ah, the calm, literal-minded fellow. Now, how to explain it all? Both to Balm and to us the audience. Because this plotline is going to involve a lot of political chicanery and diplomatic tricks, I bet...

"Sorry. I mean, metaphorically. Of all the tribes in our alliance, the New California Republic is the most powerful. But they're not as powerful as all of the rest put together, and they're going to be having difficulty occupying Arizona once the Legion collapses. So they want to arrange things so that the summit very obviously doesn't favour them too greatly."
And ideally arrange for the Arizona territories to be ceded to them for management, I would imagine.

Balm nods. "They wish to appear magnanimous, and so encourage us to accept their leadership."

"That's part of it, but it also… Makes sense. For the members of the Enclave tribe, it is part of their… Religion? That the United States didn't collapse at the end of the Great War, it just entered a period of turmoil."

"You told me that it had been two hundred years."
See, most countries at conflict for that long would be considered disbanded in a fraction of that time. At least Rome had a measure of continuity of government, though the throne moved from place to place, from Rome itself to Constantinople...

I nod. "A long period of turmoil. They all believe in it fervently. They're not always entirely sure what it is that they believe about it, but they're all faithful. So while you and I both know that you're the chief of the Ammonites, and therefore paramount chief of… What do you call the area you rule?"
It doesn't help that some of the polities involved in this would likely not recognise the tribal confederacy as a legitimate government because it isn't like classic American governments.

"I would usually call them 'our lands'. Or I refer to the rivers which bound them."

"Paramount chief of this region, then. But they believe that this region is called Utah. And while they don't care if a people who call themselves Ammonites live here, under their law the chief of the Ammonites has no significance."
Aye, there's the issue. American governments have always had trouble getting along with extant peoples in territory they claim... 😅

"Why should I care about their law in my lands?"

"You said that you would not insult someone else's god?" He nods. "This is their god, the nation that fought the Great War. They can be reasonable about many things, but not that."
They might not see it that way if you say that to them, though. Best not to use the g-word in that manner...

"So I put on the war paint of the Governor of Utah, and that gives me standing in their law?"

"Yes. And it's a lot easier to understand for people further away, like Valentina Rosado, who apart from speaking to Tears for a few minutes has never met anyone from the Ammonites, or anyone other tribe in this region."
And it's only going to be worse if anyone from the East Coast states is attending, who won't grok the subtleties.

"She is-. Ah." He smiles. "One of my daughter's co-wives."

"No-. Please don't ever say that. I have met her husband-."
Another thing to not mention around the other Governors. Balm is really going to be an odd fit amongst them...

"The machine-" He stares. "-did not check that she was unwed?"

"She kept her maiden name, so I suspect that Doki just assumed that she wasn't married."
If she bothered to check in that much detail at all. She might just have looked up 'most beautiful women of the region'... Somehow... And picked the top three...

"Ah."

"Valentina is President of The Republic of the Rio Grande. But because Rio Grande was a state before the war, she'll be addressed as Governor during the conference, just as Grant will be referred to as the Governor of California."
I'm guessing they absorbed part of the United States of Mexico before the war began, then, since the river flows out of Colorado, down through New Mexico and into the Chihuahua and Coahuila states of Mexico. Though given those names, I can see why they called it 'Rio Grande'...

"And… Am I the Governor, under their law?"

"Each of the states had their own rules on how governors were chosen. If the people of Utah have chosen you, that's enough. But… One of the things we'll be discussing is how governors should be chosen in the future."
Essentially standardising things across all the states, then. Mostly to prevent some warlord strong-arming their way into the seat, I would bet.

"The governor of a state. Which need not be the same as the chief of the Ammonites."

"Yes."

"Hm." He nods. "And what of you?"
Whoa, I don't think Krono has anywhere near the free time to be a Governor.

"The land of the Sky Walkers is part of the State of Nevada, but we don't really have a candidate, and… New Reno was effectively annexed by the N.C.R. after Doctor Anderson's forces ravaged it. Us sending a separate Governor wouldn't really make sense at the moment."
So they'll sit out the agreements, and hope the NCR doesn't play silly-buggers with their sovereignty. Admittedly, with Krono and the Area 51 tech under their control, they do have enough muscle to make themselves heard if needed.

House doesn't want the job, none of the Wrights have a high enough profile -I mean, I don't blame them for running and hiding when Anderson stormed the city with Enclave power armour divisions, but it didn't exactly earn them acclaim-, Lynnette… Thinks of most of us as uncivilised savages, Vargas has a good reputation but he wants to move back to Arizona as soon as possible, and I… Haven't spent enough time working in this state, which isn't yet in any position to function as a state. Balm works because his tribe conquered Utah, while Grant works because the major cities in California voluntarily came together and backed him. Nevada's not there, nor anywhere near there.
With any luck, the nascent United States will recognise pre-war borders, adjusted for territorial shifts. Especially if the ones calling for reunification can shout loudly enough...

"You will not attend?"

"No, I'll attend. And I'll be running around in the background. I just won't have a special title." I sigh. "I don't know. If it's really necessary I'll try and get Lynette to agree to Hernán Vargas being our 'Governor', but it would look… Silly."
I doubt Vargas would accept anyway, if he's that determined to return to Arizona. Maybe present it as 'Interim Governor'.

"Do Grant Hayes and Augustus Autumn wish to return to life their god, the United States of America?"

"Augustus does. Grant could go either way, but… It's not a bad set up for administering a lot of territory, and the N.C.R. isn't very good at controlling territory away from its core cities."

"I have been able to use freed slaves and minor tribes to control the lands that were the property of the Eighties. Chief Thunderbird did something similar to take tribute from the weaker tribes he ruled. Why does Grant not do the same?"
Because how do you trust the people you put in charge to do the sensible thing? With the tribes, you know them personally, and can call them out if needed. But some NCR git put in charge of a whole region might get ideas.

"Well, in the example of the Mojave, the people weren't unified enough to join as a group, or enthusiastic enough about the N.C.R. to become citizens and govern their own affairs. When the N.C.R. conquered the Rapids and the Baja peninsular, they moved in large numbers of people who were already Californians in order to control the land. But between the Legion and the lack of water, no one really wanted to move into the Mojave so that wasn't an option."
So annex it but don't push too hard to occupy it? At least until you can extend military control over it.

He nods. He's uneducated, not stupid. "If the paramount chief of a state is called a Governor, what are the lesser chiefs called?"

"Mayors. Usually, a settlement of any size would have a mayor, though only the mayors of larger towns and cities would be considered important. Mayors report to the governor."

There's a faint smile on his lips, though I'm not sure-. "And who is above the governors?"
Ah, that's going to be the sticking point for the conference, I would think...

"Strictly speaking, no one. The Governor is the highest government authority where matters pertaining to their own state are concerned. They usually work within a framework of laws, and if they go against those laws there are people who have the power to refuse them-" He nods. Balm isn't an absolutist. He's used to having elders he needs to explain himself to. "-but that's within the laws of the state. The United States of America Supreme Chief who held the title President-."
Because America really obsessed over the individuality and autonomy of states back during the founding years...

"Ah. That is why the Presidents are calling themselves Governors."

"Probably. Otherwise, it would get confusing."

"And what does this Supreme President do?"
Also, calling yourself 'President' at a meeting like this would send the wrong kind of message about you intentions.

"Deals with things outside of the United States of America, deals with problems between states, and controls the military of the whole of the country. That's the… Simple version. The full version is a good deal more complex. Presidents tended to try to centralise power to themselves at the expense of the governors… But even if our alliance becomes more like the United States of America I suspect that the office will be far more limited."
Since the states are used to their relative independence at this point. Much like that period of the First Continental Congress before the Revolutionary War really turned hot. This series of Extra History is a good primer on that.

He frowns. "Governors do not have soldiers?"

"Not exactly. They have armed police for fighting raiders and criminals, and they have a militia called the National Guard, but most of the military was controlled by the President."
The Militias being an essential thing because the national military technically can't operate on their home soil without special legal conditions.

"We do not have a President. Does Grant want to take that title?"

"I don't think he'd mind getting it, but we're not unified enough for anyone to accept someone having that degree of power over them."

He nods. "Good."
Hopefully those most likely to want the seat don't make too much of an ass of themselves.

"And we couldn't perform the proper ritual for choosing a President anyway. Not until all of the lands of the United States are allied to us. No, at this stage we're just reorganising allied states and working out how best to support one another."

He nods slowly. "Then that is something that I can do."
It would be a bit awkward if they had separate Presidents on the East and West Coasts. Especially when they finally meet in the middle...

Well, hopefully Balm can avoid any social gaffes caused by cultural misunderstandings while acting as Governor. Especially if Krono can offer advice. I'm guessing he'll be running around smoothing over those sort of ruffled feathers alongside preventing arguments between armed security details for each visiting dignitary...
 
13th February 2284
15:48 GMT -6
It's so reassuring and refreshing to hear things laid out like this. I have heard some praise for conditional monarchies recently, so this was pleasant. I suspect most of the games would require a major time investment to understand the lore from this level.

I enjoyed this more than reading an overview from a wiki or other summary, more than 95% of video essay channels. Maybe because the overview is so broad, and no one is trying to be funny? Is it just this earnestness that I crave? Or maybe it's the storyteller in me.

Thanks for the chapter.
 
"Ah!" I nod as I fold up the briefing document some well-meaning Shady Sands spod who was probably unfamiliar with his audience and pass it back to Balm. "Okay, I think I understand where they're coming from."
'made by some'?
"Strictly speaking, no one. The Governor is the highest government authority where matters pertaining to their own state are concerned. They usually work within a framework of laws, and if they go against those laws there are people who have the power to refuse them-" He nods. Balm isn't an absolutist. He's used to having elders he needs to explain himself to. "-but that's within the laws of the state. The United States of America Supreme Chief who held the title President-."
'America had a'?

I wonder if Krono is doing the classic thing of discounting himself from governorship while everyone else wants him to have the job, or if he's actually correct.
 
Thank you, corrected.
Balm is totally going to appoint Krono as a Mayor, isn't he?
No, he can't. The Sky Walkers aren't under Balm's authority, and are closer to the N.C.R. anyway. He doesn't want to start a conflict with his son-in-law or their powerful ally.
'made by some'?
'America had a'?
Thank you, corrected.
I wonder if Krono is doing the classic thing of discounting himself from governorship while everyone else wants him to have the job, or if he's actually correct.
Want him? No. Be willing to accept him as the best person to negotiate for them? Yes.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top