• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

What are your most hated fanfic tropes

The holy trinity by far is Dumbledore, Ozpin, and Hiruzen, but I encounter it in a lot of other fics too.
It's a synthesis of multiple things:
1) The main character generally needs to grow and establish their place in society for an arc, and needs to do so themselves because character growth.
2) The "Dumbledore" of the situation could easily solve that issue, or at least remove whatever unfair barriers there are that the writer puts in to get their underdog-kick off.
3) The authority figure is far, far too incompetent to actually leverage their position to help, despite that being in their best interest.
4) No incompetent person could make it as stupidly far in society as the authority figure did.

The verdict? Well, if they can't be as dumb as they look, they gotta have a secret motive.
 
1)Realistic fics, more specificly when authors justify characters being absolutely braindead. Ship of Theseus is the pinicle of this trope but I've come across plenty of lesser examples.

2)When MCs are treated as less capable than they are by people that should know better. An example of this was a naruto si fic (not as naruto) where the MC had Shaper with a range of self, and had shown that they knew more about biology then anyone else. Then when Tsunade discovered he gave himself gills (I think) she told him he was being irresponsible and didn't know what he was doing. Like I'm sorry what, he's already shown he knows more about the field you specialize in than you do. Additionally you don't know how long he was working on it or what precautions he took. She just immediately assumed he was being an irresponsible child.
 
This one probably has an actual name somewhere, but I like to call it "Dumbledore syndrome". Basically, why is it that any time there is a person in authority that a) doesn't immediately share every value and belief the protagonist has, and b) has knowledge they don't immediately share with canon mc or fic mc, they the must be secretly evil? Bonus points if they are actively fighting an evil force and or operating in the best interests of the people they protect, and double bonus if they happen to be an old man. The holy trinity by far is Dumbledore, Ozpin, and Hiruzen, but I encounter it in a lot of other fics too. And worst of all it usually just gives of the vibes of projecting based on distrust of IRL government as opposed to even being grounded in its own story.
Stories like Harry Potter require a very specific level of incompetence from authority figures. It's usually fine when you're just reading or experiencing the story for the first time, but with repeated reading or when analyzing the story (as you do when you're trying to write a fanfic), it starts hurting your suspension of disbelief and demands to be fixed or at least addressed. Especially when at other times the stories portray them as extremely competent.

Take Dumbledore for example: At times he's shown to be a wise and powerful wizard, Grand Sorcerer, Supreme Mugwump, the vanquisher of Grindelwald, etc. So... why does he allow Dursleys to abuse Harry? Figgs is right there on his behalf, and she outright says that she didn't dare treat him nicely because then Dursleys wouldn't let her babysit him any more, so clearly he must know about it. Why does he forbid Harry's friends from sending him letters, cutting Harry off from wizarding world completely for the summer? Why, at the end of PoA, does he not use the timeturner himself? He could have captured Pettigrew and proven Sirius' innocence easily enough if he wanted to.

The Doylist explanations are easy enough to understand. If you want a Watsonian explanation, you have to provide it yourself. And malice is the one favored by Occam's Razor.
 
1)Realistic fics, more specificly when authors justify characters being absolutely braindead. Ship of Theseus is the pinicle of this trope but I've come across plenty of lesser examples.
I find that fics that make a big deal out of being 'realistic' are often dark, edgy, and/or centered around a few ideas that the author came up with and won't stop fluffing themselves over. These fics are rarely actually 'realistic', the author just thinks they're smarter than the in-universe characters and wants to 'prove' it. Sometimes that means they try to juggle 'what happens in canon' with 'I'm so smart, I have to justify everything' and make the characters do dumb shit with flimsy justification. Other times they just straight-up add dumb shit without realizing.
 
This one probably has an actual name somewhere, but I like to call it "Dumbledore syndrome". Basically, why is it that any time there is a person in authority that a) doesn't immediately share every value and belief the protagonist has, and b) has knowledge they don't immediately share with canon mc or fic mc, they the must be secretly evil? Bonus points if they are actively fighting an evil force and or operating in the best interests of the people they protect, and double bonus if they happen to be an old man. The holy trinity by far is Dumbledore, Ozpin, and Hiruzen, but I encounter it in a lot of other fics too. And worst of all it usually just gives of the vibes of projecting based on distrust of IRL government as opposed to even being grounded in its own story.
This a million %. Specially with RWBY fanfics and Ozpin. The bashing of authorities figures has left a deep ingrained belief in me that any writer who so much as touches this IP is incapable of writing a convincing narrative if it involves these characters in any meaningful way or the obvious allegory for IRL systemic racism (aka Faunus) ever becomes a focus point.

Honestly its so overdone and cliche that I can essential predict word for word, anything that involves these 2 topics in any RWBY story that I read or watch.
 
This a million %. Specially with RWBY fanfics and Ozpin. The bashing of authorities figures has left a deep ingrained belief in me that any writer who so much as touches this IP is incapable of writing a convincing narrative if it involves these characters in any meaningful way or the obvious allegory for IRL systemic racism (aka Faunus) ever becomes a focus point.

Honestly its so overdone and cliche that I can essential predict word for word, anything that involves these 2 topics in any RWBY story that I read or watch.
OMG yes, this and the whole Dxd "none of these factions are nice to humans, I want to keep my humanity". People seem to forget that Dxd is more 40k with tits than Pjo, and also convinently forget that most of the human factions have been by far the worst ones (church and hero faction both working on active genocide), but people get so upset about the slavery implications of the devils that they start to obsess over it. A really good example of this I think is Danzydanz, his writing is really good but I can't handle his Dxd fics because of the obvious barebones for the devils.
 
This a million %. Specially with RWBY fanfics and Ozpin. The bashing of authorities figures has left a deep ingrained belief in me that any writer who so much as touches this IP is incapable of writing a convincing narrative if it involves these characters in any meaningful way or the obvious allegory for IRL systemic racism (aka Faunus) ever becomes a focus point.

Honestly its so overdone and cliche that I can essential predict word for word, anything that involves these 2 topics in any RWBY story that I read or watch.
They fear the job applications. :V

It is an ingrained belief in fanfics that if it can't be my way then it is wrong.

Unless every demand is met, they won't consider it a victory.

So any authorities that try to implement a restriction, the author is unwilling to compromise.

Leading to all these stories about going against the establishment and bashing characters for being part of a system.
 
They fear the job applications. :V

It is an ingrained belief in fanfics that if it can't be my way then it is wrong.

Unless every demand is met, they won't consider it a victory.

So any authorities that try to implement a restriction, the author is unwilling to compromise.

Leading to all these stories about going against the establishment and bashing characters for being part of a system.
Many times they don't even bash the system for what it actually does wrong and instead choose random moments to shit on it
 
They fear the job applications. :V

It is an ingrained belief in fanfics that if it can't be my way then it is wrong.

Unless every demand is met, they won't consider it a victory.

So any authorities that try to implement a restriction, the author is unwilling to compromise.

Leading to all these stories about going against the establishment and bashing characters for being part of a system.
Yeah. I see this mostly as a consequence of western politics (and the purity tests Therin) leaking into the fanfiction people write. There's definitely more of a "my way or the high way" mentality there then there was previously.
Many times they don't even bash the system for what it actually does wrong and instead choose random moments to shit on it
"But they don't agree with me, therfore they are wrong. They don't agree that I'm right, despite me not putting forth any substantive argument they are wrong, therefore they must be evil, because I'm right!"
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top