• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

Pax's Alternate History Snippet repository.

I hope,that you would have not-commie Siberia,too.People there deserved better.There is cruel soviet joke about that:
Czukcze/siberian tribe/ before revolution know only two kind of feeling - hunger and cold.After revolution come third - endless gratitude for soviet union!

jokes aside, Kołyma in OTL was practically death camp - less then 5% send there survived.Here,it could be normal gold mine.Sometimes they would find mammoth - i read memories of polish survivor from such mine,one they found frozen mammoth and eat it quickly.
Other animals,too.


Logistic - making logistic for mechanized unit was hard.Germans failed during taking over Austria and Czech,their tank divisions practically stopped.If there were war in 1938,there would be no blitzkrig.
In 1939 they were better,but even then Guderian corps lacked fueal,and they were saved by soviets,otherwise they would be sitting duck.
soviet mechanized corps in 1939 failed,too.

Your China till 1938 would be probably only country on Earth which could do that properly.

about clvary-mechanized unit - i read some memories of polish soldier,who on 1940 had french friend in one of their motorized calvary unit - it failed,and calvary could not keep with mechanized infrantry.They plan to fully mechanize it,but lost war.

last thing,about guns - what about using 120-127mm guns from destroyers as heavy artillery? of course,they need wheels,but it could be done.
 
I hope,that you would have not-commie Siberia,too.People there deserved better.There is cruel soviet joke about that:
Czukcze/siberian tribe/ before revolution know only two kind of feeling - hunger and cold.After revolution come third - endless gratitude for soviet union!

jokes aside, Kołyma in OTL was practically death camp - less then 5% send there survived.Here,it could be normal gold mine.Sometimes they would find mammoth - i read memories of polish survivor from such mine,one they found frozen mammoth and eat it quickly.
Other animals,too.


Logistic - making logistic for mechanized unit was hard.Germans failed during taking over Austria and Czech,their tank divisions practically stopped.If there were war in 1938,there would be no blitzkrig.
In 1939 they were better,but even then Guderian corps lacked fueal,and they were saved by soviets,otherwise they would be sitting duck.
soviet mechanized corps in 1939 failed,too.

Your China till 1938 would be probably only country on Earth which could do that properly.

about clvary-mechanized unit - i read some memories of polish soldier,who on 1940 had french friend in one of their motorized calvary unit - it failed,and calvary could not keep with mechanized infrantry.They plan to fully mechanize it,but lost war.

last thing,about guns - what about using 120-127mm guns from destroyers as heavy artillery? of course,they need wheels,but it could be done.
In the longer term the 5 Inch naval guns will start showing up once the great caliber (barrel length) argument gets settled but this will also be division and corp level Dual Purpose artillery during the war to make Japanese bombers go away historically even though Japan couldn't march troops that far inland due to supply limitations and lack of roads and rail infrastructure Japanese bombers struck Xian and Chunking here the Japanese Air services (navy and army) have reason to push for better strike aircraft and there is a stronger engine market during the late interwar period so you have a driving reason to introduce specialized air defense artillery which will eventually become the Army's Air Defense Command.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATP
In the longer term the 5 Inch naval guns will start showing up once the great caliber (barrel length) argument gets settled but this will also be division and corp level Dual Purpose artillery during the war to make Japanese bombers go away historically even though Japan couldn't march troops that far inland due to supply limitations and lack of roads and rail infrastructure Japanese bombers struck Xian and Chunking here the Japanese Air services (navy and army) have reason to push for better strike aircraft and there is a stronger engine market during the late interwar period so you have a driving reason to introduce specialized air defense artillery which will eventually become the Army's Air Defense Command.
If i remember correctly,Japan Navy G3M bombers had range which let it bomb most of China - but it burned so easily,that even biplane Curtiss,not mention I16 could schoot it dawn.So,they could not use it without escort fighters even against Czang.
Against your China it would be massacre.

to be honest,dunno why war start here at all - in OTL some soviet agent among Czang army probable provoked it to made Japan fight China, not soviets.

Your China would not attack Japan to help soviets.

P.S You mentioned FT 17 with better stronger engines - it mean,that you practically made either Fiat 3000 ot T18, not FT17.
 
If i remember correctly,Japan Navy G3M bombers had range which let it bomb most of China - but it burned so easily,that even biplane Curtiss,not mention I16 could schoot it dawn.So,they could not use it without escort fighters even against Czang.
Against your China it would be massacre.

to be honest,dunno why war start here at all - in OTL some soviet agent among Czang army probable provoked it to made Japan fight China, not soviets.

Your China would not attack Japan to help soviets.

P.S You mentioned FT 17 with better stronger engines - it mean,that you practically made either Fiat 3000 ot T18, not FT17.
The problem here is still in Japan's case, the government after the Kanto quake and certainly after the 27 banking crisis just has no leverage to actually meaningfully keep the army cliques in line, yes in theory one of the other cliques could have won out but here, Yamagata the younger is already in declining health (by contrast Yamagata the elder dies aged eighty something, Isaburo dies at like 69) and the anti bolshevik wing of the army is still beefing with the traditionalists over doctrine because they wanted more machine guns and artillery and this was Pro Anglo Alliance camp in the army which is arguably why they got purged in Tokyo's political infighting.

Tokyo GHQ in this period had already established they could not control junior officers inside the Kwantung army and this by the time 1932 rolls around has escalated to the point that individual group commands of the IJA are actively threatening officers from other group commands in public (the US attache to Tokyo comments on this) which is the whole problem with how the japanese army has set itself up as all of the old meiji hands die off.

As for referring to improved FT 17 here its because its being used as a generic, I've mentioned this previously, but in period a lot of what are called renaults or FT17s seem to actually have been Fiats or fiat like versions of the Renault that were domestically produced (particularly since some of them are expressly stated to have 6.5 Italian machine guns) so FT17 is the Generic Name for any tank of this type.

When we get to the air defense build out, well Xian has a built a lot of railways so the first 127mm air defense guns are going to be on trains because they're defending cities against a novel threat profile, then later will move to large tractor trailer configuration for towing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATP
June 1925 New
June 1925
In 1905 Allen had found himself attached to the Japanese 4th​ Army and in July he'd been in Fengtian for the meeting old man Yamagata had seemed to dominate and the papers had been triumph at that the goals of modernity of the meiji restoration and so on had been achieved. Twenty years on hew as presiding over the herculean task of modernization, and to create a rich country and thereby support a strong army. A rich country meant people not worrying where the next meal was going to come from.

Yuan Shikai had adopted western traditions heavily from Prussia, including the march which the bands still played. Allen tucked Tani Hisao's letter of happy army day... the holiday japan had adopted in 1906 following. It was dated from March, but it hadn't arrived in China proper until the end of May. Such letters hadn't been unheard but the delay to it did raise some questions since a letter from Japan should not have taken but a week or two prior to it actually getting to him.

"Wonder what crossed his mind to write?"

Hisao was a theoretician and logistician, and his letter reminded him with its reminiscing about the war as Akashi's talks. Allen wondered whether Black Jack had gotten a similar letter of if this was just a matter of the old man's lingering presence. "I have half a mind to ring Pershing,"

"His letter might not have gotten there at all."

He nodded, "True, this could be about Iseburo though. He's demanding more money for railways in Siberia saying its national security. I think he got persnickety about the shell shortages when asked about his budget and embarrassed some folks." Iseburo might not have been army but his patronage and pedigree as Yamagata's heir allowed him the ability to support the calls for modernization. It was ironic since the old man had wanted larger divisions not more of them... but Iseburo was a supporter of the modernist doctrine, and alliance with England to box in the soviets.

Dawes leaned against the window and looked to the band currently giving the undersecretary from Shanghai fits, his fingers stained with red ink."You going to call Hisao at the school, he should be at the staff college."

"Hisao agrees, he thinks the Bolsheviks will try again."

"We all think they'll make another go of it, just a question of when." Dawes replied, "Where does that leave them?" Iseburo wanted an alliance, his whole theory of national defense hinged on international cooperation and trade to curtail possible bolshevik aggression. AN Anti communist alliance of the British Empire, Japan, the US and China which would be able to collectively fuel quantitative trade and qualitative industrial grown. Naturally in this grand idea the Royal navy would deny the soviets trade in the event of war by sea in the west, and well... after that point Iseburo got a little shaky since he didn't want to explicitly say the allied armies would need to march across asia and to seize moscow, the Bolshevik capital, from the east... with only vague references to historical sweeps across the steppe.

but, "Hisao has basically said that the deficiencies of mobilization in the campaign," the Russo Japanese war, "Must be addressed..."He's skirting the official line of the College on the war pretty closely now." Enough to potentially get him into trouble.

"And the states?

The US role in this was fiscal and industrial, and if necessary a strategic reserve, "Iseburo figures that if the Russians try to go for this revolutionary bridge nonsense again, or invade the baltics the-"

"He wants an American army in Europe," Dawes snorted, and shook his head," He's not going to get it, not with whose in Washington right now. Europe would have to be in an awful mess for the congress to think sending an army back over there would be a good idea... and how does he propose to pay for all of this?"

Allen gestured to a map. Dawes squinted. Allen reached up and touched the pink marking Eastern Siberia under the control of Iseburo's Governor Generalship, "Iseburo is sinking money into private investments, I think he's doing the finances himself, but I think half his plan, and half of its getting ghost written by a staff officer."

Dawes looked at the eastern most bit of Siberia, no doubt preparing to go delving into those investments, "I thought the navy shut him out, some bit of parochial nonsense that we don't have to deal with." Allen shrugged, that was only true where the navy actually had the authority over certain projects but again the issues of inner clique politics, "You think Hisao is his ghost writer."

"I don't think so," It was possible of course but there were differences. A lot of the ideas both men put forward weren't new but there were differences... and if Hisao was ghost writing it unless Iseburo had specified them there should have been fewer. "The ideas look related though."

The 'Combined Figure' army navy spending in 1903 had been a third of Japan's budget. A share that was unfathomable even discounting the navy's spending from that. That had been an absurd amount of money in 1903 and, a painfully large portion of a budget to consider for Allen at the time, and one which had required Japan to take loans out to support even before the onset of hostilities against the Tsar.

"Percy's on his way up," Dawes noted stepping away from the window. "And as for the both of them, you should call him, he probably knows that the lower house is going to be more inclined to to get belligerent with Peking with Feng there." Dawes paused to make another grumbling about Feng's politics and his religious leanings, "And thats another thing-"

The door opened and a major stuck his head in. "Mister Graves is coming." The cavalry officer remarked.

"Thank you Major." Allen replied from the desk, "Can you go ahead and tell Wang to bring in the tables for steel production, and rolling stock for the Zhengzhou drafting."

"Yes sir." Dawes looked at him as the Major moved back and had a short conversation in the outer office. "He would like to know if you want total steel production documents, and the machine tooling figures as well."

"I would if they're handy, you can send Percy in when he gets in. Shan as well whenever he arrives." The papers all came in on an ugly metal cart, which had probably been bought sometime around the time the first office here had been opened. Documents for the 'new rails' and the diesel line that would go from Xian to the lake bound up in a smart looking packet. The investment in machine tooling, and increasingly heavier large presses were helping to drive urbanization in Qwinghai, and Xinjiang...

Even though the files on that weren't here, that also meant building housing for workers. That was something going on in Kirghiz as well since it too was urbanizing. That drove small building firms, as well as craftsmen and added jobs to the economy. Which of course was a deep hole to dive down on any sort of day. The major put a telegram on the table from Powell. "Just in."

"Thank you, major." Allen unfolded it and scanned it as Percy appeared from the elevator, but Shan was probably still out with the cavalry regiment on exercise supervising the practice of recovering vehicles.

"Immigration?" Dawes guessed.

"By proxy. The earthquake a year and a half ago did a number on Tokyo." He remarked, "Powell I think would have liked to have done more to help, but the Navy shipped pre fabricated housing from San Francisco as quickly as they were able." Since the states had passed the immigration acts though Powell's MAK had encouraged Japanese, and Korean migration to middle America, and where he could to his project in Liberia and the new rubber concession. Catching the ding of the elevator he changed subjects, "Remind me what Iseburo did with his white russian artillery?"

The head of the artillery service didn't bother looking at Percy as he came in, thankfully without the undersecretary from Shanghai dogging his steps, and closed the door. "Pushed them into standard units, replaced the old stuff," Russo-Japanese war era guns, "with Schneiders." Dawes paused, "Did he commercially purchase those guns?"

"Oh yes, gold I believe," Percy remarked speaking up, as he stepped past the cart overloaded with papers, "Some mine in Siberia, I think. It starts with a K, he's in good with the family firm that runs. Significant share holder in the project as I understand."

"Right, was it because the Navy complained about the budget for new artillery?"

"He did take the decommissioned eight inch guns and put them on railway artillery to protect the border against the Bolsheviks." Dawes stated, "But I'd say you be better off asking him about personally especially since he's buying those Mikados from our yards."

Percy noted that those were also probably being paid for from gold from magadan in the kolyma river basin.
--
Notes: Yuan Shikai when he established the beiyang army continued the process of modernization of preceding efforts this included the formation (though some sources say the Huai Army of which Yuan had belonged have claimed they already had a military band) of a military band and the adoption of German military marches, including that of Prussia Gloria, as well as their own divisional songs. [Admittedly the British probably adopted playing the march before ww1, and lili marlene is a thing in the British Army as well]
 
Last edited:
Kołyma is not gold mine,but many.And it was known that there is gold before WW1 - considering that Kolyma till after WW2 was not connected by road with rest of Russia,it is really strange that nobody in OTL keep it after 1920.Soviets could do notching there till at least 1945.

Russian guns - in facts they were schneider 122 and 152 howitzers, i think that they do not built any russian gun.
Just like soviets before WW2,to be honest.they only developed old guns with germans help.
 
Kołyma is not gold mine,but many.And it was known that there is gold before WW1 - considering that Kolyma till after WW2 was not connected by road with rest of Russia,it is really strange that nobody in OTL keep it after 1920.Soviets could do notching there till at least 1945.

Russian guns - in facts they were schneider 122 and 152 howitzers, i think that they do not built any russian gun.
Just like soviets before WW2,to be honest.they only developed old guns with germans help.
I know, and you know that, but here they're referring to a piece of the ass end of Siberia which produces gold so it technically being several mines being run by one company (a Sumitomo subsidary), and in this case its being used to buy larger Schneider post war guns to replace that frankly most of the White Russian guns were in poor condition hence being a step towards modernization.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATP
I know, and you know that, but here they're referring to a piece of the ass end of Siberia which produces gold so it technically being several mines being run by one company (a Sumitomo subsidary), and in this case its being used to buy larger Schneider post war guns to replace that frankly most of the White Russian guns were in poor condition hence being a step towards modernization.
Then, they could modernize them,too, like soviets did in OTL - their "new" 122 and 152 howitzers made just before WW2 was,in fact,Schneider guns modernized with german engineers help - longer guns, bigger chambers,and new chasis and wcheels so trucks could pull them fast.

and, how Kołyma mines help Japan before WW2? mayebe they would be rich enough to tot start WW2 here.
And oil fields - they existed both in Siberia and Manchuria.Fun thing - japaneese knew that there must be oil in Manchuria, they look for that, but missed it every time.
Poor dudes, with oil there they could not start war,too.

P.S interesting, that russians for unknown reasons changed caliber - 152 howitzers instead 155,and 107mm heavy guns instead of 105.Only 122 howitzers remained the same,dunno why.
 
Then, they could modernize them,too, like soviets did in OTL - their "new" 122 and 152 howitzers made just before WW2 was,in fact,Schneider guns modernized with german engineers help - longer guns, bigger chambers,and new chasis and wcheels so trucks could pull them fast.

and, how Kołyma mines help Japan before WW2? mayebe they would be rich enough to tot start WW2 here.
And oil fields - they existed both in Siberia and Manchuria.Fun thing - japaneese knew that there must be oil in Manchuria, they look for that, but missed it every time.
Poor dudes, with oil there they could not start war,too.

P.S interesting, that russians for unknown reasons changed caliber - 152 howitzers instead 155,and 107mm heavy guns instead of 105.Only 122 howitzers remained the same,dunno why.
Oh this is the funny thing the above mentioned inter service shit between the Japanese Navy and Army, the Navy knew there was oil on Sakhalin that could be exploited, what the Navy couldn't get was appropriations to get investment to bring in technical expertise to actually exploit the dig site because it would have meant having to compromise with the army and agree to bring in foreign expertise during the immediate post war years (which here of course instead of leaving Japan is holding Sakhalin).

The IJN leadership refused to develop the oil field because it would have required that compromise, if they couldn't do it in house they didn't want to do it at all. The civilian government decides they can't make the Navy compromise so it sits there, and nothing happens similarly most geologists recognized there should be oil in Manchuria the problem was one the navy was in a state of transition between coal to oil and didn't have the expertise to handle the digging (and again wasn't willing to consent to bring in Britain (who they had previously worked with) or the post bread up portions of Standard Oil (who had experience in North China).

The beef between the IJN and IJA is a great example of how political internal rivalries shoot countries in the foot.

as for artillery, I have a bunch more stuff to read on that both regarding soviet adoption and reasoning, and what Japanese modernists might actually want or be able to procure in 25-28-33
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ATP
Oh this is the funny thing the above mentioned inter service shit between the Japanese Navy and Army, the Navy knew there was oil on Sakhalin that could be exploited, what the Navy couldn't get was appropriations to get investment to bring in technical expertise to actually exploit the dig site because it would have meant having to compromise with the army and agree to bring in foreign expertise during the immediate post war years (which here of course instead of leaving Japan is holding Sakhalin).

The IJN leadership refused to develop the oil field because it would have required that compromise, if they couldn't do it in house they didn't want to do it at all. The civilian government decides they can't make the Navy compromise so it sits there, and nothing happens similarly most geologists recognized there should be oil in Manchuria the problem was one the navy was in a state of transition between coal to oil and didn't have the expertise to handle the digging (and again wasn't willing to consent to bring in Britain (who they had previously worked with) or the post bread up portions of Standard Oil (who had experience in North China).

The beef between the IJN and IJA is a great example of how political internal rivalries shoot countries in the foot.

as for artillery, I have a bunch more stuff to read on that both regarding soviet adoption and reasoning, and what Japanese modernists might actually want or be able to procure in 25-28-33
It would be funny,if it was not tragic.i once read book about soviet artillery,when i found it,i would tell you.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top