• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

Mudsnake (Harry Potter Muggleborn!Slytherin!SI)

Thanks for the kind words! :)
Company fic? I'm not familiar with the term.
Its fics centered around the Waifu catalog cyoa. The company in question is a omniversal organisation who hands "stamps" and superpowers to their contractors. Anyone getting stamped by a contractor gets mindcontrolled into loving the contractor and sees convincing the agent into stamping more people as the logical solution to about near everything.
Stamping gets the agent "points" to buy waifus and superpowers.
Stamped people get their near infinite clones sold by the all-powefull company.
 
Last edited:
This is by far one of the best fics I've read in a long time with a Self-Insert tag (and I've been on this binge for the better part of the past decade, now). Kudos to Fulcon, and I'll expound on my more detailed comments below.

It's hard to pull off a start like the way you did, in media res without giving the reader a look into the character while writing a Self-Insert fic. I find your method both refreshing and unique in many ways, and the latest chapter prior to this post does a great job at tying that part up neatly. It serves both as an open ended question for the reader as well as a very effective resolution to what the character is doing outside of Hogwarts. More importantly, the characters are so flighty, so untethered because we're reading it from Sullivan's perspective so far, and that is very difficult to accomplish, when most SI authors tend to make sweeping assumptions about the characters they have read about, and navelgaze about it. The central conflicts that arise with a typical HP Self Insert are rather well resolved, and I am glad that I read something written in this style, about such a fun character.

A few of the deus ex machinas are pretty outlandish, especially the usage of the Room of Requirements in the story, but I suppose it is necessary for plot purposes, though it does raise more questions than it answers, given that Dumbledore and the other profs presumably know about him sneaking off there to...do whatever. And learn Occlumency. The in-universe in-character justifications that Snape and Dumbledore (supposedly) have given for this is that a Muggleborn in Slytherin...needs it? Okay. It's desirable, off course, that he should have some means of protecting his own mind, but this is undeniably very advanced magic, very few people outside of the supposed prodigies of their era even know about it. And "Tom Riddle" didn't have much of an issue, as far as we know, as a Muggleborn (at least until he figured out his own heritage), so there seems to have been some sort of Overton Window shifting in blood purity politics in the British Wizarding World since after Voldemort's rise, though that would certainly be ironic.

Vince and Crabbe not being dumb ogres in this fic is also very cool, and it's nice to get such a glimpse into them as well. Daphne, while somewhat overdone, is also a well-written character in this fic, I thoroughly enjoyed reading how Marcus views her and her actions through his own lenses, and the hint towards the end that makes me think that there's morex and that it's going to be fun reading and figuring that out.

No comments on Draco, really good work on that aspect.

Loved the scene with the vase. The way it was written, it kept me hooked, and on my toes the whole time. The way the dialogue was timed, the way the stakes were shown and not stated, it all came together really well. A lot of the background work there, including the interlude with McGonnagall and the Trio, and how Harry found them, worked really well, and gave something fresh to the plot that I haven't seen before. Good work on keeping Marcus pretty much on the slightly above average end for magical talent, so far. Wonder if that will change? No worries either way.
 
Progress Report:

Chapters Done: 10 (+2)

Word Count: 33.5k (+6.2k)

– Status: Stalled.

Regrettably, I've fallen ill and under the weather, so work on the story has stalled while I focus on recovery. Thanks for your patience, everyone!

This is by far one of the best fics I've read in a long time with a Self-Insert tag (and I've been on this binge for the better part of the past decade, now). Kudos to Fulcon, and I'll expound on my more detailed comments below.

What a fantastic comment! Have a cookie, you wonderful person. :D

It's hard to pull off a start like the way you did, in media res without giving the reader a look into the character while writing a Self-Insert fic. I find your method both refreshing and unique in many ways, and the latest chapter prior to this post does a great job at tying that part up neatly. It serves both as an open ended question for the reader as well as a very effective resolution to what the character is doing outside of Hogwarts. More importantly, the characters are so flighty, so untethered because we're reading it from Sullivan's perspective so far, and that is very difficult to accomplish, when most SI authors tend to make sweeping assumptions about the characters they have read about, and navelgaze about it. The central conflicts that arise with a typical HP Self Insert are rather well resolved, and I am glad that I read something written in this style, about such a fun character.

I'm glad you like it. It definitely felt like opening with Marcus getting to the room of requirement was inspired. In my experience, when I would navelgaze about a character, its because I was trying to fill the space and wasn't sure where the plot was going to be going. Glad to have avoided that this time, that's for sure. :)


A few of the deus ex machinas are pretty outlandish, especially the usage of the Room of Requirements in the story, but I suppose it is necessary for plot purposes, though it does raise more questions than it answers, given that Dumbledore and the other profs presumably know about him sneaking off there to...do whatever. And learn Occlumency. The in-universe in-character justifications that Snape and Dumbledore (supposedly) have given for this is that a Muggleborn in Slytherin...needs it? Okay. It's desirable, off course, that he should have some means of protecting his own mind, but this is undeniably very advanced magic, very few people outside of the supposed prodigies of their era even know about it. And "Tom Riddle" didn't have much of an issue, as far as we know, as a Muggleborn (at least until he figured out his own heritage), so there seems to have been some sort of Overton Window shifting in blood purity politics in the British Wizarding World since after Voldemort's rise, though that would certainly be ironic.

You'll have to bear in mind that both Snape and Dumbledore are accomplished legilimens and while Marcus's defenses really aren't that good, they're both able to put two and two together. Marcus's mind is getting better defended –> He spends an awful lot of time up in the Room of Requirement –> He's obviously learning Occlumency up there.

And yes, Occlumency and Legilimency is advanced magic, that's why he's only approaching competency after an entire year of study. He's not even planned to become a 'master' until the third year.

Also, Voldemort is a half-blood, not a muggle-born. His mother came from one of the Sacred 28 wizarding families; the Gaunts.


Loved the scene with the vase. The way it was written, it kept me hooked, and on my toes the whole time. The way the dialogue was timed, the way the stakes were shown and not stated, it all came together really well. A lot of the background work there, including the interlude with McGonnagall and the Trio, and how Harry found them, worked really well, and gave something fresh to the plot that I haven't seen before. Good work on keeping Marcus pretty much on the slightly above average end for magical talent, so far. Wonder if that will change? No worries either way.

Why thank you. I appreciate the kind words. :)
 
And yes, Occlumency and Legilimency is advanced magic, that's why he's only approaching competency after an entire year of study.
I'm not expressing too much skepticism about this one element, I hope. It's very nitpicky, but I was just concerned that it would become Occlumency wank, when all we know about it is that it prevent a Legillimens from invading a wizard's mind at leisure. Of course, I am eager to see how you use your creative license to breathe life into its mechanics, as you have done with the whole Merlin portrait, and Wandless Magic aspects. It's a neat bit of worldbuilding that I really enjoyed!

Also, Voldemort is a half-blood, not a muggle-born. His mother came from one of the Sacred 28 wizarding families; the Gaunts.
He didn't know that in his first year! It took him, I believe, until his third year to figure out the Gaunt connection too, iirc!

Edit; If I forgot to mention it, get well soon! Health is, of course, the most important thing. I look forward to your swift recovery!
 
Last edited:
I'm not expressing too much skepticism about this one element, I hope. It's very nitpicky, but I was just concerned that it would become Occlumency wank, when all we know about it is that it prevent a Legillimens from invading a wizard's mind at leisure. Of course, I am eager to see how you use your creative license to breathe life into its mechanics, as you have done with the whole Merlin portrait, and Wandless Magic aspects. It's a neat bit of worldbuilding that I really enjoyed!

I hope I'm not coming across as overly defensive, myself. I do appreciate your comments.

And I'm afraid I can't take too much credit for the stuff like Wandless magic, as that is actualy something Rowling herself introduced after the series was concluded.

He didn't know that in his first year! It took him, I believe, until his third year to figure out the Gaunt connection too, iirc!

Ah, I see your point now. Have a cookie.

If I had to think about it, I'd say that there was still some doubt; he was an orphan not specifically a muggle-born. His parents could've been anyone. Though that is an argument I'm making in response to you, not necessarily something I thought about extensively.

If I forgot to mention it, get well soon! Health is, of course, the most important thing. I look forward to your swift recovery!

I appreciate it. :)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top