• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

[RWBY] RWBY Shorts

also they all love cloaks but do they love Guns like Ruby?
It's an evolutionary thing actually, Guns weren't invented yet, so they all found a big strong himbos to throw them really, really hard and fast.

The SEWs who found himbos thrived and passed on their genes, and after a few generations, you have valiant warriors with a biological sleeper agent code deep in their genome.

Ok but on a serious note, holy shit how hard are they trying to bait people?
 
One possibility they are trying to start a shipper war. The other it's completely unintended because they have no interest in a male/female pairing.

How crwby's rwby would end
the_end_of_team_rwby__by_codyandgwen_dn8ieou-414w-2x.jpg
 
Last edited:
As someone who enjoys AUs as a way of exploring characters and how they work, here's a concept I shared on discord but never in a thread: Regency Era RWBY AU.

Basically, take the characters, and figure out how they would fit in a version of Remnant that's looked through the lense of a Jane Austin novel.

Ellie Dashwood's channel is full of information on why everything worked. Not that one is required to get it down one to one, but it's important to know why something is there before you decide to use or not use it.

So, let's say this is a remnant some time in the early 1800s - given Andrew's worldbuilding has canon happen after the year 2000.


So first off, for better or worse class is a critical role for the setting. So we need to iron that out.

Weiss and Blake are easy. Weiss is a stupidly wealthy merchant family daughter, and Jacques would be pressuring her to marry someone with a title so that they can elevate from Landed Gentry to the Aristocracy. Blake being a princess gets her high standing, but Menagerie wouldn't be looked on favorably as a new nation, with them being Faunus or color nails who caught off their overlords playing a role dependent on the story one wants to tell. She would feel pressured - not necessarily by her parents, she could come up with this idea on her own - to marry someone with a shitload of money to help build up the nations coffers.

Given how an Austin novel goes, the ideal situation would be if Blake had a younger brother, then Weiss and Blake could solve each other's issues immediately.

Given that Grimm should be part of the setting - otherwise you can just take a Jane Austin novel and change the names - Huntsmen and Huntresses should be strongly regarded. IRL becoming a soldier and rising to an officer rank would easily see a commoner be welcome among the gentry and Aristocracy.

So Tai and Qrow would be able to walk in the same circles, thus Ruby and Yang also have the same opportunities as Weiss and Blake, and the same societal pressures, no matter how much Tai feels them they don't.

Raven running away to be a bandit makes for excellent material to make a scandal hurting Yang's prospects, both in romance and as a Huntress if one wants to go that way.

Pyrrha also would be in the same ballpark, but may be seen as higher than Yang and Ruby due to her skills and her own independent wealth.

Jaune in Canon is from a former royal family. Ergo, he is the prince of a kingdom. So him showing interest in anyone is great drama for plots.

In Discord someone suggested Ren being the last son of a noble family from Mistral. With Nora as his loyal maid. Excellent scandal when he takes her as his wife.

As for villains, I think Roman has the best in, in a Regency Era story he would be either a highwayman, who had some romanticization going on, or he could be a fortune thief for a darker story. Though the laws of inheritance and marritin remnant likely may not strictly allow that plot to work.
 
Well, I could rework it so that it's just that Whitley has no idea where to start with guns as he wants a gun of his own. So she drags him off to go gun shopping!

Which for Ruby may as well be like picking out engagement rings.

Accidental proposition.

Anyway, speaking of Schnees and speaking of weapons; what do you think would be a good secondary for Weiss? Or would two weapons plus support sorcery with her glyphs be too much work?


The Atropos, a sailing ship that moves around the Ever After. It's a ship of dreams and memories, literally. For passage on it, you have to exchange a memory or dream to the crew. I named it for one of Horatio Hornblower's ships and the one of the Three Fates and was known as "the Inflexible One."It was Atropos who chose the manner of death and ended the life of mortals by cutting their threads. Members of the crew are often those who sold all their memories and now are slaves to it.

The sea of Noon. It's a sea locked in time, nothing changes. Glibfish swim through the sea. You can live forever in it, but you never change. You never grow. This existence is all you ever have, you often revert to a child.

This is good. Very thematic. Most appropriate, and I like the mechanics.

I should lay out what I have for the Haunted Forest and the Dreaming City.

Haunted Forest - a thickly forested realm populated mostly by oak-like trees with trunks about twenty to fifty feet across. Many of the trees are either knotted into appearing to have faces, and several that aren't have jack-o-lantern like faces carved into them. The ones that have fires lit in their mouths are capable of talking. And summoning.

It doesn't have a day-night cycle. It has a night-dusk cycle. It is easier to see in nighttime because of the stars that light up the sky. Dusk, on the other hand, is almost pitch black and you need to rely on the trees and the spirit lanterns to see more than ten feet ahead of you.

The ground is swampy, and roots provide obstacles for mobility. As do the grasping hands of the myriad cadavers beneath the water and the earth.

Ghosts come out of the spirit lanterns and are universally mindless and hostile.

Half-man/half-buzzard creatures swoop down from the trees to attack the living. And I want to squeeze in a cursed stone statue if I can.

Speaking of squeezing. I'm also tinkering with folding Balamb Garden but an entire platforming game into the Dreaming City.

The Dreaming City is meant to be a labyrinth of light and rainfall. One where the E.A.'s particular hatred for rules, logic, time, space, sequence and so on are on full display.

I imagined something like a Escher-noir cross between a futuristic city from a kart racing game and a casino level from an older Sonic. But I am wondering if I cannot fold the flying witchcraft military academy and the sewer platforming into that. Because it feels like that might be overkill, or too much (fuck, those feel like dirty words).

Principal hazards include motorists who drive and fight like they are in a karting game, on top of the fact that reality and consistency run at the edges. The fact that you can sort of tear your environment away like movie/stage props and a back curtain (no promises as to what is behind it - there was an Ed Edd n Eddy episode here that comes to mind) not to mention that you may find yourself spontaneously respawning or catching yourself in a stable time loop after iteration two or three… Which, as you can imagine, makes pool hustling really, really interesting.


More Yang Branwen stuff would be great. Jaune trying to get her to talk to her dad Taiyang again could be interesting.

She attacks Tai to see what he's made of, turns out he can still kick her ass. That earns him her respect.

Once Yang is confident that Tai is the man that her mother said he was, her first request will be his blessing to marry Jaune.

And she tries to play Jaune up, by listing all of his good points that Taiyang shares… according to Raven's diary.

She will do this in public.


-Jaune gets his pickup truck from his folks on the farm but now he has to take everyone everywhere for trips, rides, etc. Yang also has to run errands for Ruby and her team since she also has a driver's license and vehicle. Jaune drives them both out to some secluded place where they drink beer his family sent him and complain about being the only two with driver's licenses and vehicles. Romance ensues.

Good idea. Yang is probably the best drinker of Team RWBY and JNPR unless Jaune's Semblance goes in. Strawberry Sunrises usually contain 2.5 to 3 shots worth of alcohol each and you will get drunk on them very quickly. If those are Yang's go-to, she can hold herself together pretty well.

-Jaune was a character in a Lost in Space style show when he was a kid. He is really embarrassed by it but someone rediscovers it-Yang. Yang loved it and Jaune's character... So nerdy crushes ensues.

I never saw Lost in Space, so the frame of reference is lost on me.

But for nerd crush, I have another idea. They meet at a game or other media store - both having tracked down some obscure video game or anime ova. There is one left and they both want it.

They reach out to grab it, their hands touch, boom.

-Yang is so frustrated with Jaune and Pyrrha's inability to romance. So she decides she'll make Pyrrha jealous enough to make a move by dating Jaune herself! As long as feelings don't get involved... Everything will work out! Right?

If I were to tackle this, I'd have Yang try and spell it out for Jaune, that this started off because of his own fumbling the bag with another girl in his life, but since he is denser than osmium, he'd assume that she has been talking about Weiss. At which point, Yang screams, throws up her arms, and decides that she is now going all in on her own marital happiness with the dum-dum, and damn the consequences.

-Jaune realizes his role in his team, aside from commander, is to be the tank. So to be an effective tank, he has to be able to take punishment and dish it out. Pyrrha is teaching him technique... But he needs to learn how to take a beating and keep going. And only Yang is willing to fight him and cut loose. So they train, hard.

Jaune having two mentors at the same time feels like an echo.

Counteroffer: In the wake of the Vytal disaster. Jaune is hungry for blood. The person who was supposed to teach him how to fight is dead, and he knows what he needs to work on. So he seeks a friend who he has some measure of confidence in with respect to her capacity for violence.

The fact that Jaune is willing to place faith in her and not treat her as an invalid does wonders for Yang's confidence and things go from there.

Yang builds Jaune up into a warrior. Jaune builds Yang back into a woman.

I'd definitely have this take place during the winter months between V3 and V4.

-The Rusted Knight meets Yang first when she's separated from the rest of RWBY in the Ever After. Due to time manipulation, they're alone together for a long time while they try to find the others. Things get tense, they fight, they kiss and make love to deal with their isolation.

I'll let you in on a secret. I am toying with the idea of having Yang Branwen bump into the Rusted Knight.

Which, naturally, led me to wondering at what an E.A. sort of Yang would be, and I settled on what I call the Azure Dragon.

Yang Branwen relies a little more, well a lot more, on the acres that I made up. But, she came to peril in the Haunted Forest, and got turned from the path. She started subsiding on the local flora. And the airborne creatures once she realizes that they are corporeal and not rotting.

Eventually this metastasizes into an ability to eat spirits. And to see them once she leaves the E.A. I admit, I am inspired a bit here by a South Korean horror movie that I know of.

But whereas Jaune becomes the Rusted Knight, Yang becomes a glitch in the Curious Cat and Jabberwockey's system. Her weapons stop needing physical ammo and I've got a few other ideas that haven't finalized yet.

And while I principally had this idea for Yang Branwen, I think it or something like it could work for Yang Xiao Long as well.

The Dreaming City was meant more as an adventure for Neo.


I'd appreciate that.

Right then. You're sound-minded and I like you, so I apologize if I come across as over-litigious, terse, harsh, or contemptuous at any point, but I know you well enough to know that you know me well enough to know that is just how I structure sentences. You're obviously passionate about these characters and I am entirely cognizant of that fact and fully capable of appreciating it, even if I do not share said passion about them. If anything comes across as pejorative I only mean the ones I aim at CRWBY and their competence.

The issue before us is that I cannot write Team _NPR.

This is a predicament on my end is that I do not find these characters interesting, but writing around them is cumbersome when circumstance and reason place Team _NPR near the center (at least initially). I do not wish to write badly or have my work suffer.

I like to write about Jaune Arc (RWBY's choices for male leads are few).

Jaune Arc is the leader of Team JNPR, which has four characters (Jaune Arc, Nora Valkyrie, Pyrrha Nikos, and Lie Ren).

But I struggle to write Jaune's teammates.

So, why is that?

The simple answer is that I do not think that they are interesting. What the show, RWBY, gave me and what I understood that to be prevented me from either enjoying them on screen or wanting to ask any "what if," about them in the fanfics.

Let's unpack the 'what' and the 'why' of that.

The key to Team JNPR is Jaune Arc. To understand JNPR, we must understand who and what Jaune Arc is. Jaune Arc's job in RWBY is exposition. Jaune is introduced as buffoon who needs to learn about the setting and world as we (the audience) do. His excuse for being in RWBY is our excuse to learn about Remnant. This is corroborated by the fact that he is voiced by one of RWBY's principal writers. Therefore we can take the questions that Jaune asks about the setting and world in which he lives, and the answers that he receives, as the author being true and sincere with us (not that it does any good).

Jaune was put into RWBY so we can learn what everybody on Remnant has no reason not to know. This coincides with Jaune being a punchline character. Nobody can accuse Mr. Luna of writing a self-insert power fantasy/DMPC if his character only there to be laughed at.

But they cannot just have Jaune around, asking stupid questions. He needs to look like he belongs there. So he needs teammates. Enter Nora, Pyrrha, and Ren. I tentatively think that this is corroborated by the fact that Team JNPR was designed comparatively late in development for characters introduced as early as they were. For everybody who doesn't know, Team SSSN was designed before Team JNPR.

Therefore, Team _NPR's excuse for being in RWBY is Jaune. You cannot build your system around teams of four and then introduce four girls + one clueless guy unless you're making a harem anime. They can also interact with the main cast as a function of Jaune's relationship with the main cast. This is corroborated by the structure and, more importantly, absence of their interactions. Jaune is friends with Ruby and pursues Weiss. I cannot readily recall a substantive interaction besides the food fight in V2 between Teams RWBY and JNPR that isn't centered around Jaune. Example: Ruby activating her Silver Eyes. Pyrrha is Jaune's teammate, Ruby is friends with Jaune, so CRWBY expects us to take it as written that Pyrrha's death would effect her and they felt no need to actually build a relationship between Ruby and Pyrrha.

This is how CRWBY handled Team JNPR. From V1 to V3 we define, as we are expected to define, Team JNPR in terms of Jaune. This is established in the formation, structure, plot, and character interactions formalized in the Jaundice arc, and followed by the next two volumes as the framework by which we understand, and by which we are meant to understand Team JNPR.

Therefore, I never considered Team _NPR as characters in their own right, nor did I find any reason to. Narratively speaking, they are part of Jaune's Beacon uniform. And the Jaundice arc, as much as I dislike its presence, goes to great lengths to affirm this interpretation.

For example: In RWBY, I found the drama plot between Ren and Nora in V8 to be wholly unnecessary, utterly moot, and I do not think anybody would notice or care if it did not happen, or even if Ren and Nora were wholly absent from the story by that point. It was just a make-work plot put there because some of the most incompetent writers that I have ever seen had two characters who they needed to put to work - lest they help out - and couldn't think of a way to write them out or kill them off even though their purpose in the story had already been fully served as of V3. CRWBY tried to spin it off into a Ren/Nora arc in V4, but that was just a diversion that had no lasting impact on the story, and CRWBY could not think of anything to do from V5 and beyond to make them relevant.

But, what was the Jaundice arc, and why did it preclude me from seeing anything worthwhile in these characters?

The Jaundice arc is the character arc of first impression for Team JNPR.

Jaundice introduces us to four characters, each having their own place in its internal plot, its structure, and the broader story of RWBY. So, to understand my understanding of Team JNPR and therefore, my disinterest in Team _NPR, we must look at what the Jaundice arc gave me and what I came away from it thinking.

Jaune is the one who the writers mean for us to care about. He is introduced as the butt of a joke and spends the Beacon intro/Emerald Forest arc as a punchline so we can learn about the setting. Jaune being an idiot, and uniquely dense when it comes to Weiss rejecting him is meant to be funny and CRWBY couldn't bother being clever. Uniquely for Team JNPR, he is meant to have a character arc, meaning, and relevancy to the story of RWBY, but the Jaundice arc's climax tells us loud and clear that none of that will happen until Pyrrha dies.

Nora - loud, quirky(trademark), off-kilter girl with short, orange hair who is there solely to spout off quotes for t-shirts on the Rooster Teeth store (one of two introduced in V1).

Pyrrha - The third leg of the Jaune-cannot-take-a-hint running gag that didn't bother leaving the couch. Her schtick is having an unrequited crush on a punchline character that he is completely oblivious to by dint of him being a punchline character. Jaundice starts by establishing her as a catalyst for his growth, and concludes by saying that said growth will only come when she dies. Until whence, Jaune remains a punchline.

Ren - a placeholder. He's the one we are supposed to look at, say "hey, he's voiced by Monty, neat," and move on. His character is fused at the hip to Nora's so CRWBY didn't have to spend time or effort giving Jaune unique, meaningful, in-depth relationships with three whole characters.

That is Team JNPR as they were given to me, and what I had then understood them to be in October 2013.

I do not have a high opinion of CRWBY's literary competence. They wasted their very limited time that could have been spent introducing the main characters saying "here is a diversion about a punchline who will matter later on, Penny, the girl whose death is meant to tell the audience when 'later on' is, and some guy." I had said "fair enough" and waited for the story return to the characters who I thought RWBY was about.

Then Pyrrha died, and Jaune became involved in the story in ways besides embarrassing himself. But the school setting was gone, and with it the hard rule on teams of four. Nora and Ren without anything to do in RWBY's story. CRWBY gave us Kuroyuri because we were four volumes in and a pair of side characters that I had felt perfectly safe to ignore because Jaundice established that they would principally only affect each other and that their relationship to the story would only be tangential at most up until CRWBY thrust these two background characters into the spotlight and needed to do something with them. It worked for V4, but I cannot conceive of anything meaningful or substantive that they did in V5 or beyond that both mattered to the story of RWBY (what was left of it anyway) that could not have been done by someone else whose development would have better served the story itself.

This isn't limited to Nora and Ren doing nothing beyond Kuroyuri, I have an example for Pyrrha too:

As soon as I had finished watching Forever Fall 2 for the first time, thirteen years ago, I knew that they were going to kill Pyrrha off in order to develop Jaune into something besides a punchline. Not only had the episode made their intentions obvious, but the motive too. My guess as to the same had been Monty's plan since the outset with Shane Newville corroborating as much in his letter, while mentioning that he changed it (for the worse in my opinion) at the eleventh hour.

Loathe as I am to admit it, Jaundice was one of vanishingly few examples of RWBY's writers coming up with a plan, clearly communicating the plan to the audience, and following through on the plan that they communicated, as they had communicated it, with only slight moderate bungling, and presenting that to the audience as a finished product.

But, on receipt of said finished product, I deemed Team _NPR boring. Either from that point, or because of it, I knew who they were, what would happen to them, why they were included in RWBY, and the totality of their contribution to it. All before I got attached to them. And the story went and told me that I understood everything that I had been asked to understand in the way I was meant to understand it.

That is a summary (the original was around twice as long, profusely detailed at every step, and still incomplete at time of deletion) of the story of how and why I cannot write Team _NPR. Now, to say in one paragraph what I just took 1400 to 1800 words to say preceding; their introduction made it clear to me that they were merely Jaune's accessories, they weren't meant to be anything besides Jaune's accessories, that there was never any plan to have them be anything else. The show never gave me a reason to think that they would be relevant, worthwhile, or interesting in their own right. Taking this view of them let me understand their role in the story of RWBY, why they were put into it, and their place in the setting of Remnant. They are Jaune's clothes, and they are clothes that he was meant to outgrow when Beacon fell. Beyond that, I never found anything interesting or fun about them.

But it is hard to write about Jaune at Beacon without at least mentioning them so, I decided to ask everyone else how they write these characters to see what I could learn.




How Jaune and Yang introduce Weiss.
yang_introduces_her_cute_girlfriend_by_creator5240_dncodgp-414w-2x.jpg

Perfect

Well done

Yang Arc trying to wait up for Jaune to get home.
yang_xiao_long_first_time_mom_rwby_by_theshadowofdamocles_dncpyku-fullview.jpg

They look so cute. Yang definitely looks like the baby has been doing just fine keeping her up as it is.


Oh, Whiter Rose post, yay.

First Gun

Whitley found her in the Beacon workshop, which was not surprising. What was surprising was how quickly she lit up when he spoke.

"Ruby… I need a gun." He paused. "I mean, you know guns, correct?"

Ruby's eyes went wide. She bounced once on her heels before she caught herself. "Is the Lion Pope a Tablebreaker?"

She cleared her throat, still grinning. "More seriously, yeah. I know weapons better than some graduates. So, first up—something rapid fire for suppression, or something with more oomph for bigger targets?"

Whitley considered that. "I'm unsure. Most of my security has been handled by combat teams. So I don't know who would fight through that to me. Or infiltrate in to try and kill me."

Ruby nodded, already thinking. "Definitely something with a bit of a kick, then. Just in case… Next up: how important is hiding the fact that you're carrying a gun?"

"Can't something mechashift make it easier to conceal a powerful weapon?"

"Kinda sorta?" Ruby rocked on her heels. "There's limits to that, no matter how much money you throw at it. I mean, take a look at Crescent Rose—it can fold to about the size of a carbine, but that's still pretty big for being folded up." She held her hands apart to demonstrate. "Another problem is that you need to think about recoil. Not much use carrying a gun that breaks your wrist when you fire it, right?"

"I have my Aura unlocked."

Ruby tilted her head. "Can you keep it up instinctively when you're in a stressful and noisy environment with flashing lights?"

Whitley blinked. A faint blush crept up his neck. "I beg your pardon?"

"Your Aura," Ruby said, completely serious. "Can you keep it active even when there's loud and bright explosions going on all around you, you're scared out of your wits, and there's awful smells hammering your nose like a loose nail?"

Whitley considered that. "…I… good point."

"Also, is it safe to say you've never fired a gun before?"

"…No."

Ruby nodded like that confirmed everything. "Yeah, first-timers really shouldn't try something big. That's just asking for a rough ride. So. Gotta ease you into this… though admittedly the mechashift thing you mentioned does give me an idea." She made a face. "But Weiss is gonna hate it. Maybe Winter too…"

She looked up at him. "Ever heard your dad's rich guy friends talk about shooting birds for fun?"

"Yes."

"Then you already know what a shotgun is?" Ruby's grin returned. "Because those things are pretty much perfect. And I think I can make one that you can disguise as a walking stick."

Whitley's eyebrows rose. "Huh! All right, let's try it."

Ruby's face went pink. "O-Oh…?"

"Yeah. I trust your judgment."

She beamed. "Alright. Something pump action, but with no trigger disconnect… Oh. Right! Are you left-handed or right-handed?"

"Right-handed."

"Good, good. I could make a gun that could switch between right-handed and left-handed use, but that's another failure point, more weight, and more expensive in upfront cost…" Ruby paused. "Not that that last one's a problem for a Schnee, but why make something more expensive than it needs to be?"

"That's fair—"

Ruby stepped in and started feeling along his arm, then his shoulder, completely focused. Whitley jerked. "Wha—hey!"

"I gotta feel your muscles and see what you can handle!"

"I uh—um—RUBY!"

"What? I need to check! Don't be embarrassed!"

Whitley's face was fully red now. "Do… do you do this for a lot of guys?"

Ruby's ears went scarlet. "What kind of a girl do you think I am?!"

"Uhhh…"

"I've only done this for girls!"

Whitley made a small, strangled sound. "That's… not helping…"

Ruby kept measuring his arm like nothing had happened, already muttering about barrel length and recoil springs under her breath. Whitley stood very still and tried not to think about anything at all.

Ruby exercising amazing self-restraint here.

Gotta think of a Whiter Rose EA plot now.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top