• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

The Second String: A Mass Effect Alternate History

Created
Status
Incomplete
Watchers
11
Recent readers
54

While their civilization is burning, a team of a hundred Protheans slip away to a quiet star to build their civilization anew. They have no relays, no eezo, and no way back home. What they do have is time, a hospitable world and a primitive native species to enslave to build their empire. A species they call humanity.

Made with Claude.
Timeline New

Mingo

Son of a Hazmot
Joined
Apr 30, 2020
Messages
477
Likes received
5,089
Note: For clarity, I will be using OTL names and terms for the timeline. The chapters will use TTL names and terms though. Other than that, consider this timeline as if written by the victors and treat it accordingly. Click the links to read the associated chapter, hover over the underlined words to see additional information (if you're on mobile, tap them). If you find any of this confusing let me know.

c. 9,728 BAWC — A Prothean expedition led by Tavar the Deciever destroys the Charon relay, severing Sol from the galactic relay network. The expedition settles on Earth, establishes its capital of Akreth, and begins preparations for humanity's integration into Prothean society as slaves.

9,728–9,653 BAWC — The Protheans slowly establish themselves as humanity's patrons, trading advanced tools, medicine and food for labor. Through language, trade and growing dependency, they begin transforming nomadic human populations into settled communities under Prothean control. Under Tavar's direction, ectogenesis technology and state-run creches fuel a rapid expansion of the Prothean population, laying the foundations for later imperial rule. [1] [2]

This timeline is a work in progress!
 
Last edited:
Arrival New
The relay died in silence, and the silence was the only mercy in it.

Tavar watched from the forward platform with his hands clasped behind his back, the way he had stood through every briefing of the war. Beyond the viewport lay the empty black between the stars. Behind the ship, so faint it was hardly more than one bright point among many, hung the system's star. Around them drifted the slow, frozen debris of the system's ice cloud, comets and planetesimals older than anything alive.

They had towed the relay out for twenty-six days, and the ore-heavy rock beside it for nineteen more, and every hour of that labor had gone into buying distance. A relay did not break the way a ship broke. When one died, everything near it died too, and the engineers had calculated, recalculated and calculated again how far out the relay had to die to spare the system.

"Impact in five," the sensor officer read off her screen. "Four. Three."

Nobody spoke. Somewhere in the dark ahead, beyond any hope of seeing it, a rock the size of a mountain range was falling toward a colossal ring of ancient metal.

"Impact."

For a moment, nothing at all. Then the black went white.

It was not a flash. A flash would have ended; instead, the light poured across the viewport until the polarizers clamped down, and even then the platform burned bright as noon and every face was painted in hard shadow. Out in the void a sphere of fire wider than a world swelled and kept swelling, and the shock of it quietly rolled toward them through the dark with nothing to stop it. The ship's auditory emulators, unable to translate the sight into any sound that wouldn't destroy their eardrums, instead defaulted to silence. When the wave finally reached the ship, the hull rang once like a struck bell, long and low, and fell silent.

"Report," Tavar commanded.

"Hull intact. Reactor stable. Minimal damage." The sensor officer's voice shook. "We are clear, Commander. The front has passed us, it's already thinning."

"And the network?"

"Dark. Nothing in, nothing out. As far as the rest of the galaxy is concerned, this system no longer exists."

Around the platform the others let out their breath. Someone laughed, some cried, most just stood in stony silence. Tavar himself did not react in the least. He merely watched the white fade across the viewport, slowly, like a wound closing, and he counted.

Nothing could survive a fire like that. That was the whole of the plan. The Enemy would see a node of its network wink out, would see the ash where a system had been, and would write the place off. It had a war to finish. It had no reason to sift through cinders.

But distance was not the same as safety. Tavar knew that better than anyone. The relays were the arteries of the galaxy, ancient machines that allowed ships to cross distances that would otherwise take decades to traverse. Without them, interstellar travel was still possible, but it was a slow, ruinously expensive business, measured in years rather than hours and limited by the fuel a vessel could afford to burn. It was how they had come: a year of conventional drive from the second-closest relay, certainly not the system's own, because a jump through the relay would have been a shout to everything that listened. Now this system was cut off from all of it. No transmissions, no traffic, no passing ships. Nothing to betray their presence. Nothing to draw the Enemy's attention. That was the theory, at least.

Tavar kept his hands clasped behind his back. His expression did not change. Inside, he was counting all the ways he could fail. The Enemy might have seen the relay's destruction. It might have detected the ship before it went dark, or followed the debris, or simply understood what had happened and why. They had built their plan around the assumption that the Enemy would mistake absence for annihilation, that it would see a dead system and move on. But assumptions were not guarantees, and the Enemy had never behaved like anything he understood. If it found them, there would be no warning, no negotiation, no second attempt. They would simply cease to exist. It was not a question of whether they could hide forever. It was a question of how long they had bought themselves, and whether it would be enough.

"Hold position," he ordered. "Nothing transmits. Nothing radiates. I want the ship darker."

"She's already running dark, sir."

"Darker."

The sensor officer opened her mouth, thought better of it, and bent to her console. Tavar felt his Second watching him from across the platform, but did not turn.



He gathered all hundred of them in the cargo bay that evening.

It was the largest open space aboard the vessel, the one place where they could stand together without crowding one another against bulkheads or machinery. Its overhead lamps had been dimmed to conserve power, leaving the gathered Protheans in the muted amber of emergency lights.

He made his way through the gathering crowd and toward the raised platform at the far end of the bay. A young officer stepped forward as he passed, reaching to clasp his forearm in the old fashion. Tavar stopped just short of him.

"Commander," the officer said. There was something unsteady in his voice. "We made it."

Tavar regarded him for a moment before giving a small, deliberate nod. "We did."

He continued toward the platform, leaving the officer's hand hanging in the air.

Among the Protheans, touch was rarely a casual thing. Their minds were not entirely their own; experiences, impressions, even fragments of ancestral memory could pass between them through physical contact. The gift was called the Cipher, and it had served their people for millenia as a means of communication and understanding. A hand laid upon another could reveal more than words ever could.

Tonight, Tavar could afford to reveal nothing.

As the last of them entered, conversations gradually diminished and an uncomfortable, awkward silence settled across the gathering. The crew had spent the last year working toward this moment, and now that it had arrived, nobody seemed to quite know what to do with it. Some looked relieved, others happy, but most shared a look of utter exhaustion. Many of them had lost their entire families to the Reapers. The rest had left their families behind, knowing they could never return. Tavar belonged to the second group.

"High Command ordered us to close this system to the relay network," he said, his voice filling the space without effort. "That order is complete. There was no order for what came after. They did not say whether we should leave or stay, or whether we should simply wait to be forgotten. Some of you may wonder whether that was mercy or an abandonment. So have I."

"Regardless, our task is done. The way is closed, and the enemy cannot walk through a door that no longer exists. But I will not lie down and die now that the work is finished, and neither will you. Whatever becomes of the war, whatever becomes of the worlds we knew, this crew will be the root of something new: a second string of Prothean civilization, one that goes on even if the main string is cut. A hundred of us, a world, and time. That is all a people has ever needed to begin again."

He raised his arms then, displaying to his people a confidence he could not feel.

"There is a world in this system that our records say is perfect for us. There are primitives on it too. A hundred of us alone cannot raise a city. In time, they will be our hands."

He watched their faces lift. A medic near the front wiped her eyes without shame. Someone began, softly, to hum, and then others joined, an old marching tune from a time when marching had led somewhere.

Tavar felt nothing but the weight of his deception. Every word had been true, except for the part he had left out. High Command had been silent on what came after, but not on everything. In the sealed lines meant for his eyes alone, the orders had been plain on one point: whatever became of this system, the primitives who lived on its world were not to be disturbed. It was High Command's wish that they evolve, grow, and develop without the influence of Element Zero or the relays on their technology.

He had read those orders a hundred times and he meant to break them. That was why he had kept his distance from the crew. The Cipher was a gift, but it was also a vulnerability. A memory shared through touch could betray what a voice concealed, and he could not risk one of his people discovering the truth before he was ready.

One clasped hand, one shared memory, and any of them would know.

They would also discover his doubts, his fears. Fears that the Reapers would find them. Fears that he was dooming an innocent species to the same fate that awaited his own people. Fears that 100 people did not have enough genetic diversity between them to support a civilization.

He stayed until the humming faded and his people filed away. Then he went to the observation port and looked at the empty dark where the relay had been, and counted again.



The world rose out of the black eleven hours later, pale and slow, the engines at a whisper. It already had a new light in its sky. The fire at the edge of the system had reached it before them, a ragged white smear hanging against the stars, bright enough at night to throw faint shadows, and it would take days to fade. Tavar looked at it for a long time. Every eye on that world had to be turned toward it.

He had studied the old records until the numbers stopped being numbers and became a kind of terrain in his mind. They were three centuries stale, filed by a research team whose names he had never learned: a world of white and grey and slate-green, its high latitudes buried under glacier, its seas wide, dark and cold. No one had come back since. It was a place made for being forgotten, and for the first time since the war began, that sounded like a virtue.

On the approach, the sensors had flagged one more thing, a silent outpost on a barren world farther out, long dead. Tavar told the crew it was an old survey station and nothing more. That was true as far as it went.

"The foothills," said Neyal, tapping the display. She was a broad-shouldered engineer with a scar through one brow, his second, and the only person aboard who spoke to him as if he were not a commander. "Terraces above the plain, with the great mountains at our back. Wide enough to farm, narrow enough to hold. Ore in the ridges, herds on the plain big enough to feed a city."

"And the warm signatures?"

"Sensors show dozens of them scattered across the plain, in clusters of thirty or forty. Camps, I'd say, each one built around a central fire, with huts or cave mouths around it." She hesitated. "Nomads, going by the way they shift. They follow the herds."

"Primitives," said Tavar. "As expected."

She looked at him a moment longer than the answer required. Then she let it go. "Do we go to them, or wait?"

"We wait," said Tavar. "We have a ship to take apart first."

It was a reasonable answer. It was also a coward's answer, and he knew it. After all, if they came to him, then he had not disturbed them, had he?

They set down at night on the terraces above the plain, without an engine flare. The hull ticked as it cooled. Frost was already forming on the outer plates. When the sun finally rose, small and yellow and thin, he stood alone on the ramp and watched the light creep down the mountainside, and, after a year in space, it looked so much like a lie that he couldn't stop staring at it.



On the second day they began to take the ship apart.

On the third evening Neyal found him at the edge of the camp, watching the ship's frame stand against the stars, and held out her hand.

A year is a long time to share a hull. Somewhere around the ninth or tenth month, he and Neyal had stopped pretending their late-watch conversations were about work. The packet of orders had stayed sealed for the whole crossing, by decree, until the day they entered the system. Until then he had taken her hand a hundred times with nothing in his mind to hide.

Now he looked at it and did not move.

"The day's survey," she said quietly. "Everything we mapped. It wouldn't take but a moment."

"Not tonight, Neyal."

"You said that last night." She did not lower the hand. "And the night before. Is it me?"

"No." And that was the truest word he had spoken in weeks. If she took his hand she would know about their true orders, and then she would have to choose between him and those orders, and he would not make her a criminal. Let the weight be his alone. "It's nothing you have done."

She searched his face for a long moment, then lowered her hand. If the refusal hurt, she hid it well. "Whatever you are afraid of," she said, "will be here whether we face it or not."

"Yes," said Tavar. It was the only answer he had.



The band came on the fourth morning.

The sentries saw them first: a line of figures dressed in furs, climbing the terraces from the plain, about thirty of them, moving slowly and in the open, the way people move when they want to be seen. They stopped at the perimeter markers. One figure stepped past them alone.

He was an older man, grey in his hair and scarred across the forearm, and he wore a string of shell beads at his throat. Someone had threaded them with patience, by hand. They were not a decoration so much as a message, from one person to another, that he was someone. Behind him stood two men with spears of fire-hardened wood, a woman with a child on her hip, and the rest of the band, small and narrow through the shoulder, with flat faces and red ochre across their brows. Most stared at the ship's frame, mouths agape in shock. Some stared at the sky, where the last ragged remnant of the relay's fire still hung above the ridge like a scar. Then their eyes came down to the strangers, and Tavar understood that these people had watched the sky burn for many nights, and had now watched it deliver visitors. Whatever they believed, it was not nothing.

Tavar had stood before the council of a dying empire. He had walked through the ruins of forty worlds. He had never felt as exposed as he did now, under the gaze of primitives.

The old man set his spear on the ground. Slowly he held out his hand in greeting, palm up and open, the way one offers something that is not a weapon.

Not to be disturbed. He had carried those words since they entered the system, and now they stood in front of him with their hand outstretched. It would have been easy to step back. But a hundred people could not raise a city, and the arithmetic had not changed, and he found that the order weighed less than the people behind him, and more than he had expected. They had come to him, he told himself. It was a lie, and it was already thin.

He nodded to Neyal. It was the smallest of movements, a lift of the chin, and it was the first line he broke.

She went forward with a soldier at her shoulder and took the old man's hand.

The old man flinched, as if a wind had passed through him. Neyal's eyes lost their focus. The Cipher took her through his life in a breath: the plain at dawn, the long hunts, a grandmother's song, a winter when the band had nearly starved, and the night the sky had burned white while every one of them huddled and wept. And with it, the whole of his language, entire, like a door swinging open.

"I have it," she said.

She would feed the language into the translation software later, when she had sorted it all out. For now she was the only bridge between them. Tavar could have taken it from her hand, as any Prothean would have. He stood a pace back instead, and let her speak for both of them, and called it a commander's dignity. It was one more thing the secret cost.

Neyal began to speak, and the strange new words, rough and guttural, rolled from her tongue. The band came forward then, and laid their gifts on the frozen ground: strips of dried meat, a folded hide, a string of shell beads. Neyal answered in kind. She gave the old man a knife of Prothean steel. He tested the edge against a spear shaft and a curl of wood fell away like butter. She showed him a fire-starter, and flame appeared without friction, and the band murmured.

Then the woman with the child stepped forward and said something in a low voice. The child's leg was swollen and hot, a gash gone bad, black at the edges. The medic knelt, cleaned the wound, and pressed a slender injector to the child's thigh. Within minutes the swelling had begun to fall, and the child looked up and, for the first time, cried aloud. The mother stared at the medic. The old man stared at the blade in his hand. It was not fear on his face but hunger, the look of someone who has seen how much easier a winter could be.

Tavar watched both their faces and understood that he was watching the first link of a chain, and that he had forged it himself. He felt no triumph. He was already counting how many would come back tomorrow, and how many would stay.

"He asks what we want," Neyal translated, "for more."

Tavar answered in Prothean and let her carry the words across. "Tell them to come back tomorrow. Tell them to bring their strong ones. We have more to give, and a great deal of work to do."

She translated. The old man considered it, then nodded once, and the band withdrew down the slope.

Neyal stayed beside him. "When I have finished translating it, what shall I call the language?" she asked. "They have no name for themselves but the people."

He had known the answer since before the landing. The old records had a word for them, coined by the research team three centuries ago, and nobody had found a better one. He said it quietly, and the sound of it hung in the crisp air between them.

"Human."
 
The Hunt New
Across the endless wilderness, five hunters moved in silence, their eyes fixed on the trail ahead.

Ulf found the first sign before the sun cleared the mountains: a hoofprint pressed deep into the wet clay at the river's edge, wider than his two hands laid side by side. He crouched and set his palm beside it and did not need to measure further. The dung a few paces back had still been dark and soft. The animal was not far, and it was very large.

Four men waited behind him without speaking. Algir, who had hunted beside him since they were both too small to lift a spear. The brothers Dav and Tolu, quick on their feet and with strong throwing arms. And Rin, the youngest, who carried the bow.

Ulf had seen it on Rin's back before dawn and had said nothing. It was a handsome thing, longer than a man's arm span, made across the border from wood that did not warp. The arrows that came with it carried heads of grey metal that never dulled. Ulf had once held one and been unable to look away from its edge.

They followed the aurochs through the morning, downwind, in single file along the water line. Twice Ulf stopped them to read the ground, and twice the trail confirmed what he had guessed. It was an older animal, heavy and unhurried, sure that nothing on this plain could trouble it. By midday they could hear it tearing at the grass.

It stood in a clearing at the river's edge, and even Ulf, who had killed eleven of its kind, felt his mouth go dry. Fur black as wet stone, taller at the shoulder than his chin, with a hump of muscle behind the neck and horns that swept forward in two pale curves the length of a man's arm. It weighed as much as the five of them together, and then some.

Rin's hand strayed towards the bow on his back.

Ulf caught the movement from the corner of his eye. He turned just enough to meet the young man's gaze and gave a small, sharp shake of his head. Not here. Not for this. Rin hesitated, his fingers lingering near the weapon, then let his hand fall. His eyes flickered towards Algir, but the older hunter offered nothing beyond a slight shrug before turning his attention back to the bull.

Ulf carried the heavy thrusting spear, its point made of the same grey metal as the arrows, though far older, worn, its edge too thin to be sharpened again. He had traded two winters of hides for it at Rin's age, over his father's shouting. He had stopped hearing that shouting long ago. He did not hear it now.

The spears the others carried were tipped with flint, knapped as their fathers and grandfathers had knapped theirs before them. The brothers went wide to the right. Ulf and Algir slid through the reeds to the left, close enough to smell the animal. Rin crouched behind with his throwing spears and his held breath.

Ulf raised his hand and dropped it.

The brothers' spears flew first, two flint points sinking into the bull's flank. The great head came up with a sound like a rockslide. It wheeled towards the brothers, then turned, and found Algir.

There was no time to move. The bull came through the reeds, its head lowered, and drove one horn deep into Algir's thigh. Ulf heard the impact above the animal's bellow. His old friend was lifted clear off the ground and flung aside, landing in the water with a cry that was lost beneath the bull's roar.

Ulf was already running.

The bull turned towards Algir again, pawing at the waterline as it lowered its head. Ulf drove forward, both hands on the haft of his spear and thrust with everything he had. The grey point struck behind the foreleg and slid between the ribs. He felt the shaft shudder in his hands as he leaned his weight against it, driving the point as deep as he could.

The bull bellowed and swung its head. The haft tore from Ulf's hands, and he stumbled backwards into the mud. For a moment the great animal stood over him, its breath steaming, its blood dark against the black fur. Then it staggered, took three heavy steps towards the river, and folded. Its knees struck the earth first, then the great bulk of its body crashed into the water.

Ulf lay where he had fallen, watching the bull's flanks rise and fall. Each breath came harder than the last. Then there was no more movement.

Ulf went to Algir.

He was alive. That was the first thing. He lay on his back in the shallow water with his teeth set and his face the color of ash, making no sound apart from splashing. The horn had torn along the thigh and across the hip, and the shallow water beneath him was already dark. Ulf pressed his hands to the wound and shouted for hide strips, and Tolu was there with them before the shout ended.

When the bleeding slowed, Ulf sat back on his heels. Algir would live, probably, but he would not hunt again. Neither of them said so.

They butchered the bull fast, because blood carries on the wind and the hyenas were never far. Ulf drew the grey knife, the one blade in the band that could part a joint clean, and worked the great shoulders loose while the brothers pulled the hide back with flint scrapers, their hands slick to the wrist. Frost still clung to the reeds where the sun had not reached, and steam rose off the opened carcass in slow white sheets. The tongue and liver came out first and were wrapped in leaves. The rest followed in heavy red slabs. When it was done, the meat lay on the grass in eight heavy bundles, with the hide rolled beside them.

Algir had watched it all from the shallows, propped against a stone with his wounds bound in strips of hide. He saw the meat steaming on the grass, guessed the weight of it, and came to a decision.

"Leave me," he said.

Nobody answered.

"Four no haul all that meat and hide and old fool with bad leg." His voice was steady, which was the worst of it. "Take meat."

"We carry you," Rin argued. "We leave hide."

"Winter coming. Tribe need hide, need meat, no need me."

The brothers said nothing. They were looking at the ground.

"Ulf," implored Rin. "Say something."

Ulf looked at Algir. His old friend was watching him, waiting.

"We come back," Ulf finally replied.

Algir held his gaze.

"We take meat and hide to camp, then come back by tomorrow's sun with four more to carry you."

Rin looked relieved. The brothers looked up from the ground, less than certain.

Algir gave a slow nod. "Tomorrow then."

"Tomorrow."

For a moment neither man looked away. There was a small brightness in Algir's eyes, something almost amused. Ulf had seen it before, countless times in their youth, when one of them had done something particularly foolish and the other had known better than to say so.

He saw it now.

The journey to camp would take most of the day and another half-day to walk back. Algir knew what that meant. Ulf knew he knew.

The wound was deep. The blood loss had been heavy. Even if the cold did not take him, there were hyenas and worse in these hills, and the smell of blood would carry a long way. Algir would be alone when the sun went down.

It was a lie and both men knew it, and that was the kindness of it.

They left him what they could: a water skin, a haunch of meat, a flint knife, and a fire lit with the drill. Ulf went to the riverbank and picked up his grey-pointed spear where it lay and drove the haft into the ground beside his friend, upright, where Algir could reach it.

"You want something that no chip," he said to Algir, "if hyenas come."

"Thank you."

Ulf took his friend's forearm and held it a moment. Then walked to the meat and lifted his share.


They walked until the light turned amber, bent under the weight, and nobody spoke. The white wall of the mountains hung in the north, catching the sun long after the plain had gone grey. Upon reaching a familiar ford that signaled they were halfway, they set down their cargo and made camp for the night.

Minutes later, a pair of ducks burst from the reeds, wings drumming. Rin had the bow off his shoulder before anyone saw him move. The string hummed. One bird dropped out of the air and landed with a splash in the shallows.

For a heartbeat, nobody spoke. Then Dav laughed, a short, cracked laugh that was not quite a laugh, and Tolu clapped his brother's shoulder, and the two of them crowded round Rin, who was grinning in spite of himself. Tolu waded in through the skin of ice at the water's edge to fetch the bird. It was a very good shot. That was the worst of it.

Ulf stood on the bank under his load. Nobody looked at him.

"One arrow," Dav exclaimed. "You see? One!"

"Arrow no worse than spear," Rin said, loud enough to carry. Then, lower, as he came back along the bank: "Algir still back there because you made us stand close. With bow would stand further back."

It struck harder than the bull had.

"Bow not teach man to stand," Ulf replied. "Bow not teach courage."

It was the kind of thing his father would have said, he realized.

His father had hated the grey metal. Said it made hunting too easy, that a man who needed the Strange Ones' grey metal to kill an animal was no hunter at all. He had said the young were growing soft, that they would soon forget how to hunt altogether.

Ulf had hated him for saying it.

He looked at the spear lying beside his pack. The grey point was worn almost to nothing, but its edge still as sharp as ever. He had carried it for thirty winters. It had killed more animals than he could count, and today it had saved his life.

He then looked at the bow in Rin's hands. The wood was smooth and dark, the grey arrowheads catching what little light remained.

And he looked north, towards the valley, where Algir lay alone beside the river.

And he came to a decision.

"Teach me."
 
The Harvest New
The reddish-gold grain stood tall and even along the river terrace, row after row looking so alike that from the ridge it looked woven.

Hesa liked the sight a little less every year.

She gripped a handful of stalks and cut, the iron sickle going through them with a soft hiss. Bundle, bind, step. She had been at it since sunrise, and her back was beyond sore. Frost lay white in the shade of the ditch, and her breath smoked in front of her. All along the line the villagers of Reed Bend worked bent double, and the sound of them, metal on stalk, a child shouting at birds, was the sound of her whole life now.

A hunt ended. That was what she could never explain to the ones who still remembered the old ways, or to the young ones who did not remember it at all. You tracked, you killed, you ate, you slept. Farm-work did not end. When the grain was cut there was threshing, and then the green roots to lift, and then the bean pods, and then the grazing flower to cut and stack for the goats. Each year the Givers taught them to do it better, and each year there was more of it. Summer crops, winter crops. It never ended.

Each field was divided in four, a section each for grain, green root, bean and grazing flower. Each year the crops moved one section over. The Givers called this rotation, and the word was theirs. Her own tongue had never needed it. There had been no word for something you did on purpose to the same ground, year after year, and she had stopped noticing when she began using theirs.

The seed was never theirs, either. The depot downriver handed it all out in time for each planting, and while every grain and root and bean could be eaten, none of it would grow again if you planted it. Hesa had learned that in the second year and decided it was simply how the plants were, or that there was some secret method to getting the crop-seed to take to the soil that none of them knew. She had not thought about it again until last year, when Dok...

Hesa straightened to ease her spine and looked down the terrace. Her partner's mother Oda, too old to cut and too stubborn to sit, was binding sheaves and complaining about it loudly. Her youngest, Pim, six winters old, ran between the rows with a clapper of sticks, shrieking at the birds to scare them away from the crops. Dok, her partner and father of most of her children, worked the last row alone, as he had all season, with his eyes on the ground.

In that final row, at the very edge of the farm, lay a patch of something else. Smaller. Rougher. Brown and bristling, nothing like the even gold before it.

She did not look at it for long.

She had been twenty-six when the Givers first came to her tribe's old summer camp. Three children, a hungry spring. They offered tools, seed and a healer. In return they wanted a people who stayed in one place to tend their strange plants, and a child, to learn their ways and carry words between them. A hostage. None of the tribe wanted to be the one to give up their child, but Hesa had said she would, because someone had to, and the band had made her Headwoman for it, as if that were a gift.

Her eldest had been six at the time, Pim's age.

Hesa did not miss the old ways of the hunt. She did not miss the hunger, or the danger, or even the taste of meat.

She only missed her son.

"Mama!"

Jos, her third son, came pelting along the terrace path, thirteen and all legs, with a grin too big for his face. "Walker on river road! One man, big pack. Carry flat board."

"The counting board." She set down the sickle.

"He walk like this!" Jos drew himself up, neck stiff, back straight as a spear shaft, hands clasped behind him, and took three stiff steps along the terrace. The nearest villagers laughed. "Say he is new liaison!"

Oda did not laugh. "Walk like bones tied," she said to no one.

Liaison. The word sat wrong in the boy's mouth, too heavy for it. Hesa wiped her hands on her tunic and went to meet the road.

He was taller than she expected. That was the first thing. Taller than Dok, almost, and broader across the shoulders. He wore grey woven cloth, clean at the hem, and his hair was cropped close to his skull. He walked as Jos had shown, with his hands clasped at the small of his back and his spine as straight as if someone had replaced it with a metal rod.

Hesa stopped.

She had imagined this moment often enough, though never quite admitted it to herself. In some imaginings he was still six, running towards her with his arms out. In others he was grown, but she had never managed to picture his face. She had always seen the little boy.

The man on the road had her father's jaw. His face was a stranger's, but it wore her son's eyes.

He stopped three paces away, and, for a moment, neither of them said anything.

"Mother," he finally greeted, in the village tongue.

The word was right, but the voice was wrong. Too smooth, too carefully formed. He spoke as the Givers spoke, without the rough edges of the language she'd taught him.

"Tam," she managed.

He smiled. And there he was, suddenly, for just a moment: the little boy who had once laughed so hard at something Jos had done that he'd fallen backwards into the cooking fire ash.

Then the smile settled into something more composed.

"You look well, Mother. Smaller than I remember, but well. The Benefactors speak highly of Reed Bend."

Benefactors. She had never heard anyone in the village call them anything but Givers. He said the word as a man says the name of his own house.

She wanted to ask whether he remembered the river camp. Whether he remembered the smell of wet hides, or the old hunting songs, or the way she used to carry him when he fell asleep on the trail.

Instead she settled on "You have grown."

He laughed softly. "I suppose I have."

"Is he Giver?"

Pim had come up behind her, the clapper hanging from one hand.

Hesa looked down at her youngest. Then back at the man on the road.

"No," she said. "He is Tam."

She put a hand on Pim's shoulder.

"Pim, meet your big brother."



At midday he set his board on a flat stone at the edge of the field. It was a slab of dark glass no bigger than a man's two hands, and it gave off a faint light when he touched it. The village hauled the sacks to him one by one, and he counted each with a stroke of his finger across the glass, and he did not hurry, and he did not look up.

Sixty sacks was the quota. Hesa had known the number since spring.

"Sixty-two sacks of sityra," Tam acknowledged. He was so used to using the Givers' speech, the Giver's terms that he didn't seem to even think about it. For the first time since he had come, he smiled with his whole face. "Good count. The Benefactors will be pleased."

A cheer ran along the line, small and relieved. "Good year," said Oda. Hesa let her shoulders drop.

"There is more." Tam had clasped his hands behind him again. "Some new tools will come this summer along with the plough-wright. Reed Bend will have them before Clay Ford. The border-watch will also send families by the next planting. Five, perhaps six, from the border camps. Villages in good standing, as you can guess, are given more hands than others."

"More mouths." Oda's hands tightened around the sheaf.

"More hands," Tam reiterated, as though the two were the same.

"And the Benefactors ask one thing more." He glanced across the faces and found hers, and his voice softened, as it does for good news. "A ward. A child of six or seven winters, to be taught in the city, as I was; to take my place there now that I will be staying here most of the time. It is an honor, Mother."

Hesa did not turn her head. She did not need to. Pim was crouched at the edge of the field, poking at a beetle with her clapper, humming something under her breath. Six winters old. The same age.

Tam followed her eyes and did not understand what he saw. "She will be well cared for," he assured. "You know I was."

It was the kindest thing he could think of to say. That was what made it unbearable.



Dok had not come to the count. He found Tam at dusk, at the end of the terrace where the last row met the reeds, and he did not say a word. He reached up and took his son by the sleeve, the way he had when Tam was small and there was something in the grass to see, and he led him down the final row to the patch.

Hesa followed at a distance. Nobody asked her to.

"Look," Dok pointed.

The wild grass still stood ragged in the last row, brown and bristling, though it looked a little less sad without the red-gold of the sityra grain standing tall beside it, each stalk the identical twin of the next. In Dok's patch, no two heads were alike. One could be fat and next thin, one bowed and the next upright, like a crowd of people.

"River grass," Dok said in the village tongue, slowly so that it would not be hard for his son. "I plant two springs back. From the bank, beside Givers' grain. Same earth. Same water." He crouched, parted the stalks, and held up a head. "First year, I keep best heads. Fat ones. Keep seed dry all winter. This spring I plant that seed. Only that." He grinned up at Tam. "It come again. Look. Heads fatter."

Tam crouched too. For the first time since he had come to the village, his hands came out from behind his back. He took the head from his father and turned it over in his fingers, and Hesa saw something cross his face that she knew. It was the look he had worn at four years old, lying on his belly beside a stream, watching an insect walk.

"How many seeds on one head?" he asked, in the village tongue, without thinking.

"I count!" Dok was delighted. He pulled a stick from his belt, notched along both sides. "First year, thirty-eight. This year, forty-four. Givers' grain make sixty. More. But no come back. This come back. Bigger each time." He saw his son's face and searched for a way to make it plain. "Like with goats. You keep the stronger ones and the next kids be better. Same with grass."

"Goats," their son murmured, as if tasting the idea.

"Same grass, same ground," Dok explained. "So I think, why this come back and Givers' grain no? Why they make grain that cannot..." He looked for the word and did not have it. "That cannot come again?"

"The Benefactors have reasons." Tam said it in the Givers' speech, at once, as a boy says something he has said ten thousand times. Then he heard himself. For a heartbeat his hands stopped moving on the stalk.

"Yes," said Dok, nodding, hearing nothing. "Reason. I want know the reason. You ask them for me?"

He said it with such simple trust that Hesa had to look away.

"I will ask," Tam answered in the village tongue.

Dok did not know there was a word for what he was doing. He only knew that he had a question, and that the ground might answer it. Hesa had watched him ask the ground questions for two years, and understood only enough to be afraid.

At Tam's belt, the counting board caught the dusk and gave back a faint pale glow. Hesa saw it. Tam, crouched in the stalks with his father's stick in his hand, did not.



She found him that night outside the hut, standing straight in the dark with his hands behind his back.

"Do not tell them," she asked.

"Tell them what, Mother?" He said it gently, in her tongue, as to a frightened child. "That my father is curious? They will be glad. They send instructors to help."

"Why they not tell us the seed does not breed?"

"It is no matter." He shook his head. "They would have told us if it mattered."

"He is your father."

"I know who he is." Then, lower, in the Givers' speech, as though to himself: "I do not have to tell them everything. It is only that I always have."

She looked at him, and saw that he believed it. He thought that was a comfort.

At dawn she stood in the doorway with Pim's hand in hers.

Tam was at the patch. He had the board in both hands, and Dok had come to stand beside him, easy as a man beside his own son, one hand resting on his shoulder. Tam did not flinch. He let it rest there as if he did not know what it was.

She could not read the Givers' marks. But she watched her son enter them, one by one, while Dok stood beside him, smiling at the thought that someone would finally answer his question.
 
Last edited:
I watched Into the West when I was in school. In the series, several Lakota children are sent to a boarding school that they were told would educate them but was really meant to strip away their culture and make them "American." The children were forced to march everywhere and even as adults, most of them still walked in a march it had been instilled in them so deeply. Those characters were the inspiration for Tam.

In this chapter, we see that the Protheans are providing seeds to humans who live in their territory (or more specifically in their farm belt) but the seeds only produce sterile crops, so as to keep the settlers dependant on them. One of the villagers, Dok, has performed an experiment and discovered that the native Earth plants, undomesticated though they may be, do produce seeds that can be sown again.

Any guesses what will happen to this family next?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top