• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • See here for information on the recent site downtime.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

Law & Chaos: Special Magic Unit (HP Chaos Gacha)

Well, Dawlish is the average political-oriented auror and Crawford was mediocre until he suddenly shifted aims.

Hypocrisy is the name of the game, but Crawford can learn from the prick how to sail the waters and get his observations once he's learned enough about the job to someone more clever and inventive than Dawlish.

Dawlish is only good for bureaucratic jobs, while Crawford can potentially become a fighter ... if nurtured.

No wonder Moody regretted not getting him! :V
 
Well Dawlish, this should be interesting.

Guys seems a bit of a prick and a stick in thw mud but from what we know he is pretty good at his job but seems to be a guy that just follows orders.


Lol I wonder why they didn't want to put Julian with Moody.

Lol Tonks being Tonks.

Huh, Mavis may not be as bad as I thought
 
"You tried to commandeer Auberon Selwyn to join your pursuit, then physically intercepted him and tackled him off his broom when he did not follow your orders."

"I tackled him to save that idiot-!"

He gave me a level look. I made myself calm down before I said something I couldn't take back.
Seems that Dawlish is a little too upset that the idiot didn't make the grade.

Dawlish is reasonably competent on paper and in canon, he has the right qualifications and everything; it's just that he consistently fails at the more physical aspect of cop work, which might be a good avenue for exploring his character too.
IIRC, Dawlish failed because he stuck to the rules far too much, didn't bend when he needed to.

No wonder Moody regretted not getting him!
I was actually expecting Moody to get all three but I suppose that was asking too much.
 
So he's got an asshole for a direct boss, but that's only for 3 years, and with the grimoire there are good chance that he becomes Dawlish superior, at which point the man will be scrubbing toilets by hand
 
Yeah in-universe there was a bit of discussion about which trainee got which supervisor.

Moody did want Julian, but both are combat oriented out-of-the-box thinkers, and there were (not unfounded) worries that they'd just worsen each other. Besides, as Marchbanks said, the Traineeship is there to teach all of the job, including the boring parts. Tonks has the versatility needed to survive Moody and under his guidance hopefully gain some coordination and confidence. Putting Smidgeworth with Moody was just asking for a nervous breakdown, so they put him with steady, nurturing Schaklebolt.

Which leaves Julian, again someone who thinks out of the box and is a clear natural at dueling and combat (and that's without them having see Elf Combat in practice. What he needs is a steady hand and someone who knows the book inside and out. You need to learn procedure before you break it. The friction comes from them not fitting together personality wise, which was pretty much the reason I settled on him, because he could not be more different from Julian.

Looking through the reactions though, I realize that in the future chapters, there's not enough focus on Julian growing magically and combat-speaking, so I'll need to find a way to add that or risk people getting bored with the story. He's building up a case behind his mentor's back though, so there's a limit to how flashy I can make it and I do want to build up on that frustration and sense that Dawlish is standing between Julian and the Gacha rewards.

I just want that frustration to stay with Julian and not be something the readers feel, but I don't know if that's possible.
 

Well, nothing stop him from getting with the others to compare notes on what they learned and teach each other when they have time. At least his management skills will get a work out. He can also learn DADA and Potion on the side (because let's be honest at Hogwarts DADA and Potion are 85% self-sudy).
 
Well, nothing stop him from getting with the others to compare notes on what they learned and teach each other when they have time. At least his management skills will get a work out. He can also learn DADA and Potion on the side (because let's be honest at Hogwarts DADA and Potion are 85% self-sudy).
Potions I agree, but wouldn't DADA at least require a sparring partner? Or is that just the duelling aspect of it?
 
Potions I agree, but wouldn't DADA at least require a sparring partner? Or is that just the duelling aspect of it?

I think partners would be needed for the most effective DADA things. However, learning to cast new spells and theoretical spell combos is probably still fair game on his own time. Admittedly, he'd want to test those out in sparring eventually as well, but it does allow for some self-study.
 
Potions I agree, but wouldn't DADA at least require a sparring partner? Or is that just the duelling aspect of it?

I think I was not clear enough but I was refering to the fact that the teachers for this subjects sucked (Potions because Snape has as much pedagogy as the university teachers I had that were teaching only because they were forced to and DADA because they get a new teacher every year with differents levels of ability) which kinda forces those wanting to pursuit them to NEWT level (or even just get theirs OWLs) to do most of the work themselves or with the help of their friends.
 
I think I was not clear enough but I was refering to the fact that the teachers for this subjects sucked (Potions because Snape has as much pedagogy as the university teachers I had that were teaching only because they were forced to and DADA because they get a new teacher every year with differents levels of ability) which kinda forces those wanting to pursuit them to NEWT level (or even just get theirs OWLs) to do most of the work themselves or with the help of their friends.
The potion thing is self-perpetuating really... I'm sure he'd be capable of teaching properly if any of his students seemed to have a level of dedication to the craft that he could appreciate... only his standards for potion crafting are skewed by the fact he is genuinely a genius in the field... thus he projects a antagonistic air to students starting from first year... thus his students rapidly lose any desire to devote themselves to potions unless they decide to do so specifically to spite Snape.
 
The potion thing is self-perpetuating really... I'm sure he'd be capable of teaching properly if any of his students seemed to have a level of dedication to the craft that he could appreciate... only his standards for potion crafting are skewed by the fact he is genuinely a genius in the field... thus he projects a antagonistic air to students starting from first year... thus his students rapidly lose any desire to devote themselves to potions unless they decide to do so specifically to spite Snape.

I fail to see how everything you are describing is not Snape's fault.
 
So where the heck are the last two ticket rewards from? Because Elf Combat is NOT in the Gacha
 
Chapter 8: The Cold Case New

Chapter Eight: The Cold Case​


​


By lunchtime, I'd managed to fully check and register four files, which was considerably fewer than I'd been hoping for.

The last concerned a stolen wand that had been recovered within a week. Dawlish had still taken statements from everyone who'd handled it, had it examined for tampering and obtained a signed receipt when it was returned. Every document was numbered and listed inside the cover. Finding things was easy enough, but I had to check each entry before signing off on the file.

I reached for the next folder before remembering that I still needed to finish the form for this one. My lunch sat beside the inkwell, the cheese at the edge of the sandwich beginning to curl.

This was going to take some organising.

Thankfully, I already knew how to do that. Sort of.

Novice Management was proving rather more useful than I'd initially given it credit for. I sorted the remaining files by urgency, set aside those requiring Dawlish's attention and worked out which reports I could finish before lunch. It was still a tedious amount of paperwork, but I dreaded to think how long it would've taken me without the skill.

By the time Dawlish looked over, I had cleared enough room to put my lunch down without balancing it on somebody's account of an assault.

"How many?"

"Six completed, sir. There's a return receipt missing from the seventh." I passed him my list. "The register says the wand went back to its owner. The file says it was sent for examination, but I couldn't find the examiner's report either."

"Which case?"

"Alderton. The incident at the apothecary."

Dawlish glanced at the list before holding out his hand for the folder. I passed it over and watched him turn directly to a statement about halfway through.

"The wand was destroyed during examination. 'Overly enthusiastic application of the Diagnostic Charm', or so I was told. The owner appealed for compensation."

I looked at the entry in the register. "So this is wrong?"

"Yes. The appeal will have its own file. Request the reference from Records and enter it on the form." He handed the folder back. "Don't mark the item as returned."

"I haven't, sir."

He checked anyway, then read through two of the forms I'd already finished. I carried on eating, trying not to watch him too closely for any sign of disapproval.

"Use the date of the final decision here," he said, pointing. "The date you have is when the report was submitted. Otherwise, carry on."

He returned to his own work. I corrected the date, finished my sandwich and requested the missing reference.

It was a small improvement on our earlier conversation, although I wasn't going to celebrate just yet. Not when I still had an entire box to go through.


Over the next two days, I learned considerably more about John Dawlish than I had during our (admittedly somewhat… troubled) introduction. Most of it made my plans for maximizing my rewards from grimoire increasingly inconvenient.

I'd started a list of investigations that might be worth another look. The grimoire had rewarded me for taking an exercise further than I'd been asked. Solving an actual crime ought to be worth something, and two boxes of old files seemed a reasonable place to begin looking for one, even if the first few were duds.

The smashed cauldron shop window had been resolved after its owner admitted to selling a man the same supposedly repaired cauldron three times. A complaint about stolen garden ornaments ended with both neighbours signing an agreement to stop charming things over the fence. The original owner of the ornaments had also agreed to stop teaching them to shout slurs in Gaelic when they landed.

I had expected a certain amount of that. There weren't so many witches and wizards in Britain that you could afford to arrest everyone who'd had an argument with a neighbour, particularly when you were likely to need that neighbour's brother to mend your roof. A surprising number of people became more reasonable once an Auror arrived and began writing down exactly what they were accusing one another of doing.

Others simply learned to be more discreet about it, something Dawlish appeared to have taken into account when writing his reports.

What I hadn't expected was how often I would reach the end of a complicated file and find that he had already dealt with everything I thought might be worth investigating.

One case involved a supplier of medicinal potions whose stock had been sabotaged, shipments stolen and employees injured. The list of suspects included a disgruntled apprentice, a former business partner, a rival firm and a driver receiving unexplained payments. Reading through the testimonies like an Agatha Christie novel, I fancied myself a moustache-less Hercule Poirot and quickly settled on the former business partner, who had access to the premises and seemed suspiciously eager to direct attention elsewhere. Several dozen pages later, I was proven right, which pleased me enormously until I noticed that Dawlish had taken nineteen months to reach the same conclusion.

My satisfaction lasted until I read how he'd actually proved it. False names, intermediaries, altered invoices, a warehouse registered to a distant relative and a curse traced through several purchases had all required separate investigations. Dawlish had interviewed witnesses repeatedly, followed up on every inconsistency and cleared each of the other suspects with the sort of persistence that made Columbo look positively accommodating. I still thought the man had a talent for overkill, but there was an important difference between guessing who'd committed a crime and proving it before a judge. By the time Dawlish brought someone to court, he'd apparently made damn sure there was nowhere left for them to hide.

The next substantial file took even more wind out of my sails. I spent most of it expecting a witch to have arranged the disappearance of her husband's valuable collection of enchanted watches. As it turned out though, it was her brother who was responsible. The statements that established his involvement had been taken months apart, and Dawlish had marked the discrepancy in the margin of each one.

Once I knew what I was looking for, it seemed obvious. Before then, I'd barely noticed that the brother had changed his explanation for why he'd borrowed a key to the display cabinet.

I stopped trying to guess the outcomes of cases for a while after that.

Unfortunately, reading more carefully did very little to improve my prospects of finding something Dawlish had left unfinished. The list I'd discreetly started on a separate sheet of parchment quickly acquired a lot of crossed-out entries. An inquiry into a disputed inheritance had ended when the family settled it privately. A wizard who wanted his former employer investigated for threatening behaviour had withdrawn the complaint after accepting his old job back.

The last note in that file was a request from Dawlish to conduct another interview with the employer. His superior had refused it.

"Did this one ever come back?" I asked, turning the folder so he could see the name.

He glanced over. "No."

"They'd already made threats against him twice."

"Three times. His wife supplied the third statement without his knowledge."

"And he went back to work for them?" I asked incredulously but Dawlish just shot me a look.

"His decision, Crawford. If he doesn't want to press charges, there's nothing for us to investigate." Dawlish finished the sentence he was writing before looking at me again. "Check that his withdrawal is included and that the decision to discontinue was authorised."

"It is, sir. I just wondered-"

"Then finish the entry."

I did, although I found myself looking back at the statement from the man's wife before closing the file.

There were others like it. People who had grown tired of answering questions, changed their minds or decided that pursuing a matter would cause more trouble than it was worth. Dawlish generally seemed to have been the last person involved to lose interest.

I still didn't particularly like him. He corrected the way I dated forms, interrupted my answers and had begun assigning Defence reading in quantities that suggested he thought sleep was something I'd got enough of at Hogwarts. But after going through his case files, I had to admit that his opinion of his own abilities wasn't entirely undeserved. He was thorough, persistent and had a habit of following up on details that other Aurors might have overlooked or just given up on entirely.

Which was annoying, because that gave a lot more weight to his dismissive attitude during our first meeting than I honestly wanted to admit.

By Wednesday afternoon, I had reached the bottom of the first box. Beneath a folder concerning a stolen family portrait was a thinner one with a faded label.

Henwick, Hester and Edith. Suspected unlawful modification of memory.

The date was four years old. I opened it, found the recorded outcome and checked that I hadn't missed a continuation sheet.

For once, there wasn't one.

Hester Henwick had earned her living dealing with the sort of creatures people preferred to have somebody else remove from their homes. She had worked in Britain and abroad, and the correspondence in the file concerned a visit to Hungary where several hags had been causing trouble. The last letter to her sister described her plans to come home and a disagreement over payment which she apparently intended to settle before leaving.

She had returned safely. A week later, on the eighteenth of April, her sister had taken her to St Mungo's because she could no longer remember having been away at all.

There was a photograph of the two women attached to the initial report. Hester was broad across the shoulders, with grey hair pinned up rather carelessly and a pair of spectacles hanging from a chain. Several wiry hairs stood out on her chin. Edith was smaller and wore her spectacles on the end of her nose. Both looked uncomfortable in front of the camera. Every so often, Hester turned to say something to her sister, who shook her head and pointed her back towards the photographer.

I read the Healer's report twice.

Edith had lost part of the afternoon. She remembered returning from an errand, putting a parcel in the hall and finding Hester in the kitchen. After that, she couldn't account for a stretch of time before discovering her sister standing at the back door with no idea why she was there.

Hester's condition was worse. Her recollection of the previous year had large gaps in it, including most of the journey she had only recently completed. The Healers had identified the effects of Memory Charms, but hadn't been able to restore what had been removed. Attempts to question her about the missing time had left her distressed and, on one occasion, violently sick.

There were notes from follow-up examinations. Very little had changed.

I looked back at the photograph. Hester had put a hand on her sister's shoulder while they waited for whoever stood behind the camera to finish.

The kitchen photographs came next. Two cups had been left on the table, along with a plate containing the remains of a cake and what appeared to be a large china rabbit. It sat upright between the cups, its front paws resting on its stomach. Somebody had painted small pink pads on its feet.

I turned the photograph over, wondering why it had been included in the investigation.

'Teapot including two cups. China. White rabbit. See statement E. Henwick, paragraph nine.' Dawlish neat handwriting was scribbled on the back, the 'two' underlined.

I found the statement shortly after.

"My brother-in-law made it for her. It was an ornament before he started. He messed up the spout though: the bit at the mouth doesn't actually do anything, nothing ever comes out of there. You have to tip it over the left ear. Hester wouldn't let anybody fix it, even after he died. She likes it that way, even if the tea does taste very Christmas-y."

I put the photograph down and returned to the report.

A neighbour had heard a man's voice through the open kitchen window earlier that afternoon. She hadn't seen him arrive. Hester hadn't mentioned expecting anyone, and Edith couldn't remember meeting a visitor when she came home.

The tea and cake had been examined. There had been nothing harmful in either, and the rabbit's enchantment appeared to extend only to keeping its contents warm. Both cups and the teapot had been collected as exhibits.

There was also a journal missing. It had travelled with her, and Edith was certain she had seen it on the kitchen dresser after her sister came home. Hester had no recollection of putting it anywhere else. Money remained in the house, including some of her payment for the work abroad. Nothing else had been reported stolen.

It was easy to see why Dawlish had been interested in the visitor.

It was considerably harder to see how I was meant to identify him once my superior had stalled in his investigations.

The disagreement over the payment had been investigated. So had the people Hester had worked for, the other travellers she had mentioned in her letters and the owner of the place where she'd stayed. Several replies were in languages I couldn't read, accompanied by translated copies. Dawlish had checked whether any of those people had travelled to Britain. He had also asked Hester's sister to account for everyone who regularly called at the house.

That produced an elderly neighbour, two relatives, a witch who occasionally brought potion ingredients round to sell and a man who had repaired part of the roof. There were statements from all of them. One of the relatives had been recovering from a broken hip on the day in question, and Dawlish had obtained confirmation from the Healer who attended her.

The journal might have explained what somebody wanted from Hester. Without it, he had been left trying to reconstruct her work from letters that mostly concerned the weather, the cost of accommodation and the practical difficulties of travelling with several jars of things liable to escape. Fairly mundane, all things considered.

I could sympathise with her sister. If I ever wrote home from abroad, Dad would probably be more interested in whether I had remembered to pack enough socks than the precise spellwork I'd been using. Unfortunately, it would make him a fairly poor source of information if someone subsequently decided to steal my memories.

The final letter from Edith asked that they be left alone by the Ministry.

She thanked Dawlish for his efforts, but explained that Hester was becoming upset whenever another request for an interview arrived and said that they couldn't tell him anything they hadn't already told him. They wanted to stop going over it. If something turned up, they hoped he would write, but they no longer wished to pursue the complaint.

Below that was Dawlish's request for permission to follow up another address. The reply declined it and authorised the inquiry to be discontinued.

I sat back in my chair. Across the desks, somebody was arguing about which office had last been in possession of a box of counterfeit Sneakoscopes. Dawlish listened to half the exchange, then told the man where the transfer receipt ought to be without looking up from his own work.

I checked the evidence entry for the tea set. They were still in storage. A note from Edith allowed for them to be kept in case they could eventually be of use, but asked if the rabbit teapot at least could be returned once the case was finished or dropped, for its sentimental value if nothing else. From what I could tell from Dawlish's note-keeping, it never had been.

The rabbit looked out at me from the photograph, its painted eyes wide and cheerful.

At least there was something to start with here. Someone had visited the house, someone had taken the journal and someone had been very thorough about ensuring neither woman could remember enough to identify him. Perhaps one of Hester's correspondents had heard something since. Perhaps there was a name in the letters that hadn't meant anything four years ago.

I glanced at Dawlish, then remembered exactly what he'd said when I asked about unsolved cases.

I finished the form, marked the exhibits as retained and then secretly copied the reference into my notebook when he wasn't looking.


By Friday, the boxes were ready for Records, just on time. Dawlish checked my forms, made me correct two entries and signed them. He then gave me a book called Dangerous Beasts and Dark Creatures: An Auror's Field Guide with the instruction to know it cover to cover, "ideally two years ago" he added with a sharp look.

Apparently, since I'd managed to get my original workload finished a little ahead of the deadline, it obviously just meant the deadline had room for more work in it.

Still, I was keeping up. Between Novice Management and the fact that Magician made the Defence reading considerably easier to understand than it had been at school, I could usually finish what he set me with part of the evening left. Sometimes it was a fairly small part. On Thursday, I spent most of it practising a particularly awkward Disarming Charm variation because Dawlish had made me demonstrate it before leaving and had been dissatisfied with the result.

I improved it. I also got ink on my pillow after falling asleep with my notes beside me, which took considerably longer to explain to Dad than I would have liked.

The Henwick case occupied the time I could spare.

I went back through the correspondence during my breaks and made notes at home. The name of a travelling apothecary appeared in two of Hester's letters, although his reply to Dawlish said that they had only met briefly. I wondered whether he might have encountered her again afterwards. An owl to the address on his old letter came back with a short note from the current occupants. He had moved, and they didn't know where.

Another enquiry produced a reply from somebody who remembered Hester, remembered speaking to an Auror about her and regretted that he still had nothing further to add.

Then there were a few references in the letters that I wanted explained. I found one in a book at the Ministry library. It concerned a way of keeping hags out of a poultry shed and did absolutely nothing to tell me who might have visited Hester afterwards. Another turned out to be the name of a local drink.

By Sunday evening, I'd covered several pages with names, dates and questions. I could account for considerable parts of Hester's year-long trip abroad, but I still couldn't identify a single person who ought to have been sitting across from her in that kitchen.

I put my notebook away when Dad called me for dinner and tried to pay attention while he described a problem at work. Halfway through, I realised I'd been thinking about whether the roof repairer might have come back on another day.

'No, Dawlish had asked him that already. There was a second statement from his employer confirming where he'd been. Just… drop it already.'

I made myself listen to Dad.


"If you break it, you fail."

The elderly wizard at the front of the workshop set a chamber pot on the table and waited for us to stop looking at it.

"If you remove the enchantment, you also fail. By the time an object comes to you, somebody may already have been hurt by it. That means the examining officer needs to know what was done to it first so that information can be passed on to the Healers, or the Curse Breakers if necessary. They can't establish that if you've blasted it into powder or spent half an hour trying every counter-charm you can remember."

I glanced down at the heading on my handout. Advanced Combat Pottery. There hadn't been a mistake on the timetable after all.

We were in a room above a ceramics shop just off Diagon Alley. Racks of cups, plates and ornaments lined one wall, all securely fastened in place. A row of worktables stood on the other side. Somebody had repaired the nearest window several times, judging by the thickness of the glass where the cracks had joined.

The instructor, Mr. Hobb, had short white hair and hands covered in old burns. He gave the chamber pot a small tap with his wand. Its handle turned towards him, aggressively so … somehow.

"Keep it intact, keep the spellwork intact and make it safe to carry away. Most of what you'll encounter today is intended to frighten somebody or ruin their lunch. You don't get to assume that before you've examined it though; sometimes, the difference between some relatively harmless Muggle Baiting that makes the palms of their hands itch is indistinguishable from a Cursed Object that makes someone's teeth fall out. Questions?"

Smidgeworth raised his hand.

"Will we be told what each object does?"

"Sometimes. Today, you won't." Hobb looked towards Tonks, who was examining a milk jug on the table in front of her. "And don't put yer hands in that missy, unless you don't mind going through life short a couple of fingers."

She withdrew her hand sharply.

My first attempt went badly. The bowl I was supposed to secure sprang off the table as I approached, and I caught it with (quite literally) inhuman reflexes before it reached my face. Elf Combat automatically supplied the needed movement to smoothly turn it away from me. Unfortunately, I followed through on pure instinct, twisting my hips automatically as I rolled with the impact and slammed the bowl onto the shop floor like this was the Super Bowl and I had just made the winning touchdown.

The crash was deafening. Somehow, the silence that came after even more so.

For several seconds, neither of us moved as Hobbs simply... stared at the wreckage and the slowly settling dust.

"Well," he said eventually. "That would be an example of, what we in the business like to call, the 'use of excessive force'. Or, as it's known by lawyers, easy money."

"It was going for my face." I said weakly as I tried to defend myself, but Mr. Hobbs was hardly sympathetic.

"Keep yer wand between you and the table. You gave it room to come at you." He placed another bowl on the table. "Keep your distance until it's secured."

I backed up a step, rather conscious of Tonks still trying (and failing rather spectacularly) to contain her laughter beside me. Her milk jug chose that moment to throw itself at her sleeve.

"Oh, come on." She desperately held her arm out, the jug's handle tightening around a fold of cloth. "I hadn't even started!"

"Don't matter: it has. Best hold yer arm still, missy. You'll pull the stitching out if you keep doing that."

I kept my attention on my own table. The second bowl struggled against my charm holding it down, a sort of inverse of the Levitation Charm that was in one of the (many) books Dawlish had foisted off on me to teach me some 'proper Auror spellwork'. At first I almost overdid it, a slight crack appearing in the bowl's glazing, but after adjusting the pressure I managed to keep it still long enough to fix it to the carrying tray. Its pattern of little blue flowers continued to rotate furiously around the rim.

Hobb inspected the tray, gave it a shake and nodded.

"Better. Now release it and do it again."

There was a rip from Tonks's direction.

"That'll be another attempt, Miss Tonks."

"The jug's fine!"

"Yer sleeve isn't. Get it off without just yanking at it this time."

Somewhat surprisingly (and a little bit frustratingly) Smidgeworth turned out to be rather good at the whole thing. He approached each object with the same care I'd seen him take around the possible Portkey during the appraisal, checked where he intended to put it and made sure he had somewhere to retreat before touching anything. His chamber pot was secured without a chip and with its lid still firmly in place.

Hobb asked him to demonstrate the process again while Tonks and I watched.

Wil looked so startled by the request that I thought he might drop the tray, but once he began explaining himself, he grew steadily more confident. Apparently, he'd once dealt with a parcel in Transportation that kept trying to roll off the desk whenever anybody stopped looking at it. The same method of keeping Schrödinger's parcel in place apparently worked quite well on hostile bathroom fittings too.

By the end of the lesson, I'd stopped underestimating how much damage a determined plate could do to my fingers. Tonks had repaired her sleeve twice, though by the second attempt there really wasn't much fabric for the spell to work with. Smidgeworth left with a written commendation for his handling of potentially hazardous household ceramics, folded carefully inside his timetable.

I thought he'd looked happy about it. When we stopped for lunch before heading back to the Ministry, however, he became rather quiet by the time the food arrived.

Tonks noticed while trying to persuade the ribbons of her torn sleeve to join back together again.

"What's wrong?" she asked. "You did better than either of us. He barely had to tell you anything."

"Oh, no, I'm quite pleased by my performance today. It's only..." Smidgeworth hesitated, then took off his spectacles to clean them. "It sounds a little silly when you say it afterwards, doesn't it? Chamber pots. I was hoping to have something a little more impressive to tell Mavis when I got home."

"I wouldn't say that within earshot of a piece of porcelain if I were you," I only half-joked, inspecting the small cut on my thumb. The edge of the first bowl had caught me when it broke. "Besides, I thought Mavis was pleased about you getting in?"

"She is. She's been very kind about it." He put his spectacles back on. "She made a cake on Saturday. Asked me to tell her what I'd been doing."

"There you are, then," Tonks said as she gave up on her sleeve. "Show her the commendation. She'll like that."

"Yes. I suppose." He picked up his sandwich, then immediately put it down again. "It's just that… she's been reading those books. Gilderoy Lockhart's, I mean. She bought the new collection, and I don't think she's put it down except to go to sleep. Last night she read me part of the chapter where he captures a werewolf with his bare hands."

Tonks made a small sound and reached for her drink. She very determinedly ignored my sideways glance as Smidgeworth continued.

"I know it isn't a competition," he added hurriedly. "I wouldn't want to do that, personally. It sounds extremely dangerous. But I'd only just finished telling her about the training, and then she wanted me to hear how he did it."

I could see the man's dilemma. Wil had spent years slaving away in a dead-end job at the office before managing to get into one of the most demanding (and thus, prestigious) professions the Ministry offered. Now, less than a week into his training, he was being measured against a man who apparently wrestled werewolves in his spare time.

Saying he had proven exceptionally skilled at wrangling chamber pots probably wouldn't help much.

"She doesn't expect you to… actually do that, surely?" I asked.

"No. Of course not. It's just... she seems very impressed with him." He looked down at his plate. "She's mentioned his photograph a few times as well."

Tonks rolled her eyes.

"Sure, he has a dreamy smile, but Mum says the man's got werewolves completely wrong. Apparently, she actually knows some, and none of them are weak to sunlight."

I looked up. "He says they are?"

"Mum heard him talking about it on the wireless. She was quite annoyed." Tonks paused to take a bite of her sandwich. "I don't know how much time he's really spent with them if he's getting things like that wrong."

"Perhaps he meant something else," Smidgeworth suggested, although he sounded rather hopeful that Lockhart hadn't.

"Perhaps. Mum didn't think so."

I'd seen Lockhart's face often enough in bookshop windows, usually smiling dazzlingly at whoever was unfortunate enough to stop in front of them. I hadn't read any of his books though. They weren't exactly Dawlish's idea of recommended reading for my remedial Defence homework.

"What's the book called?" I asked. "The werewolf one."

"Wanderings with Werewolves. It's in the collection Wil was talking about. The Travel Trilogy. That one's werewolves, then there's vampires and the one about hags."

I stopped with my glass of Butterbeer halfway to my mouth.

Hags.

Most of what I'd read about them so far had concerned their appearance, their habits and the general wisdom of avoiding them. Hester's letters assumed her sister already understood the basics and hadn't gone into much detail in how she actually managed to get rid of the dangerously conniving creatures. A proper account of somebody going out and dealing with the things might at least explain what she'd actually been doing before she came home.

It might also contain the name of someone who knew her. She couldn't have been the only witch earning a living that way. It was a stretch, but it had been almost a week since my last reward from the Gacha Grimoire and I was getting desperate here.

I'd even offered to take out the trash for Dad in the hope I'd get an achievement for being a Dutiful Son or something. Nothing. When I had then offered the same for almost everyone up and down our street, all I got of it was the thanks of several old ladies stuck behind their geraniums in the form of more hard candies than I knew what to do with and a pull in my lower back.

Still nothing from the Grimoire though and the lack of sudden growth was getting to me.

'Merlin, I hope the thing isn't turning me into a junkie… and if it is, it'd better give me another hit soon dammit!'

"Do you think the shop will have a copy?" I asked instead. "I wouldn't mind having a look. You could come with me, if you've got time before we have to go back."

"Flourish and Blotts?" Tonks asked, wiping some crumbs from her chin. "Yes, they've got loads."

"What was the hags one called again?"

"Holidays with Hags. Get the new edition, though. The one in the trilogy. He's put in extra notes and some things about the people he met that weren't in the original. There's actually quite a lot more to it now…"

She slowly stopped speaking as she steadily got more red in the face. Smidgeworth looked at her, then at me. Tonks began shifting uncomfortably in her seat as Wil and I exchanged glances.

"What?"

"You've read it?" I asked.

"… I may have… skimmed some of it. Just… to see what's new, of course! Ha ha! Ha…"

"What about the original?"

Tonks's face went red. It happened so completely that even her ears seemed to have acquired the same shade, while the pink of her hair deepened to match.

"I... well, some of it's quite interesting," she said defensively. "Just because I don't agree with everything he says doesn't mean his books aren't worth reading!"

"That's what I was hoping. I wouldn't be looking to buy one otherwise." I tried to reassure her, though I imagine the way I was fighting back a smile somewhat diminished the effect.

She gave me a narrow look, apparently deciding how much of my interest was sincere. I managed to keep my expression reasonably straight while she slowly reached down into her satchel.

The book she produced was thick, glossy and considerably less battered than anything I'd brought with me that morning. Gold lettering covered most of the front. What remained had been occupied by Gilderoy Lockhart's face, smiling beneath a title which announced three extraordinary journeys and a revised edition containing the author's personal reflections.

He had apparently found room for those in addition to the ordinary reflections already filling the rest of the book.

"You can borrow it," Tonks said, pushing it across the table.

"Are you sure? You haven't finished."

I nodded towards the bookmark near the end of the volume. She glanced at it, then at me, and pushed the book forward a few inches.

"I can... read something else."

"You mean the rest of Lockhart's collection? Or the old edition," I suggested. "You've still got that one, haven't you?"

Her blush deepened. She pulled her satchel onto her lap and fastened it rather firmly, as though that might prevent any further questions.

"Look, you're the one who said you wanted to buy one of his books, so there."

"I do. I just didn't realise I'd come to the right person. An actual fan of Gilderoy Lockhart's work, sitting right here, imagine that! Have you got his other—" She pulled out the bookmark and pushed the book the rest of the way towards me, looking thoroughly defeated as she looked down at the satchel.

I was enjoying this far too much.

"Have you got his other books in there as well?"

"Just... keep it. Please."

"Thanks. I'll let you know what I think."

"I'm sure you will." She bit back through gritted teeth as Smidgeworth followed the whole exchange like a tennis match.

Deciding to give the poor girl a break, I turned the book over. Another photograph occupied the back, this one showing Lockhart leaning against a tree with his wand resting casually between his fingers. His hair moved in a breeze which had apparently failed to disturb anything else in the picture.

Smidgeworth leaned forward to read the text beneath it. Lockhart looked up, smiled broadly and tilted his head back, his shoulders shaking with silent mirth.

Wil drew back a little.

"Is it just me... or is that book laughing at me?"

"Oh, he does that to everyone," Tonks said.

I looked at her. She took another bite of her sandwich and refused to meet my eyes.


I started reading on the way home, opened it again after dinner and found myself checking the clock considerably later than I'd intended. It wasn't all slop. Some of the things in there were actually worth knowing. In one account, Lockhart found a cellar beneath a hag's cottage by sending a charmed pebble through an open kitchen window and listening for the change in its ring as it crossed the floor, testing the ground without setting foot inside. In another, he questioned the people who delivered food, firewood and potion ingredients before approaching the occupants. They knew which rooms were used, which doors stayed locked and whether anyone had been visiting after dark.

I copied the charm into my notes and marked a passage I wanted to check against my Defence reading. Then Lockhart followed it with a page about how impressed everyone had been that he had thought to ask, including a mention of a mother who had been so overcome by his arrival that she'd needed to sit down. He generously attributed some of her distress to the disappearance of her son, although he assured his readers that he was accustomed to having a similar effect on women in happier circumstances.

I read the paragraph again, wondering whether I'd misunderstood it.

I hadn't.

Two pages later, he described how the light through a broken window had caught his hair while he confronted the hag. I wasn't entirely sure who had been in a position to appreciate that, given that he had apparently entered the cellar alone and the child was tied up in a sack. Lockhart nevertheless seemed quite confident that it had been worth mentioning.

I kept reading.

The boy was recovered, the hag dealt with and Lockhart's robes only slightly damaged (they were his favourite shade of lilac too, truly the cruelty of hags was without end). The gratitude of the mother occupied considerably more space than the spell he'd used to get her son out of the cellar. There was also a note explaining that readers interested in his earlier life would find a fuller account in the autobiography planned for the following summer.

I wondered how much earlier he intended to go. The introduction to this book had already included his birth.

By lunchtime the next day, I'd reached an account of an entire village turning out to thank him. I had spent the morning reading statements for Dawlish, and the contrast was becoming difficult to ignore. None of the people in those files had been particularly eager to even admit that they'd needed assistance from a copper. Meanwhile, Lockhart seemed to spend a great deal of his professional life being begged to accept peoples heartfelt thanks and adoration (and gifts).

Still, I could understand why Mavis was enjoying the series. Between the descriptions of his own achievements, there was a decent adventure being told, and occasionally something quite clever. I wanted to find out how the next encounter ended, even if it did mean learning how many people had asked him to stay for supper afterwards.

Tonks caught me with it open during a break and looked rather pleased with herself.

"Enjoying it?" she asked with a vindictive grin and to my frustration I had no defence.

"I'm just… trying to find out how he got out of a locked pantry."

"Oh, that bit. Keep reading, it'll take you by surprise."

"Does he stop to tell me how well his shoes were polished first?"

She laughed, then glanced towards the corridor as the distinctive 'thump' of a wooden leg hitting carpeted floor ominously closed in from around the corner and she blanched from her hair down to her toes (literally).

"You'll see. I've got to go!"

I watched her hurry off and returned to the pantry problem. The solution involved Transfiguration, a broken hinge and rather more good fortune than Lockhart seemed prepared to acknowledge. I made a note of the spellwork anyway.

The extra material in this new edition was marked out from the original text. Some of it concerned questions readers had apparently sent in. Other passages offered recollections which hadn't found a place in the first edition. Judging by what had found a place, I wasn't especially optimistic about what the publisher had originally persuaded him to leave out.

That evening, I reached an account of the hospitality he had enjoyed between two of his encounters with hags.

I was sitting at my old desk with the book propped open beside my notes. Dad had the television on downstairs, and I could hear him laughing at something while I searched the page for an actual name. Lockhart had spent nearly two paragraphs describing a widow's enthusiasm at receiving him without mentioning who she was.

She had offered him tea.

"The service itself was charmingly eccentric. Her late husband had attempted to turn a china rabbit into a teapot, with rather mixed results. Though equipped with a spout at its mouth, the creature dispensed its contents through its left ear. I confess that my hostess was so delighted by my interest that it took some persuasion to get her to sit down and tell me about herself."

I slowed, then hurriedly went back to the beginning of the paragraph.

'The left ear.'

For a moment, I could picture a photograph much more clearly than anything on the desk in front of me. Two cups. A plate with crumbs on it. A white china rabbit with little pink pads painted on its feet.

I pulled my notebook out from beneath the Defence text and found the pages concerning Hester Henwick. The evidence list was near the beginning. I'd written the reference beside it, along with a few details from Edith's statement that had seemed worth keeping.

Her husband had made it. The rabbit's mouth didn't pour. She wouldn't have it repaired.

I checked the passage again to make sure Lockhart wasn't describing something he had seen in a shop. He wasn't. He described being served from it, in a widow's home, while she told him about herself.

Lockhart might have met Hester. He also might have spoken to somebody who knew her, or heard the account elsewhere and put himself in it to make the chapter more interesting. After several hundred pages of his company, I had no trouble believing he'd improve an anecdote that way.

I still didn't know whether any of it had anything to do with what happened to the sisters.

I turned back to the beginning of the passage. There was no name, no address and nothing to establish when the visit had taken place. But for the first time since I'd opened the Henwick file, I had somebody new to ask.


AN: Really hoping I get the pacing for this right. I got a field investigation scene planned with Dawlish as well (I want him to feel like Nicholas Angel at the beginning of Hot Fuzz) but couldn't find a way to fit it into this chapter. Also, before people start asking why Lockhart doesn't immediately become Julian's prime suspect, in-universe his penchant for memory charms isn't known and practically nobody suspects him of being a fraud, so to Julian the only thing tying him to the Henwick case is a tea visit once upon a time where they presumably discussed dealing with Hags, not so much the fact that the Henwick sisters have memories missing. You can read up to 5 chapters ahead over on my Patreon.
 
Oh am I in the wrong section? Should it be in a different forum? Still kinda new to this website, so I'm unsure
There is Creative Writing and NSFW Creative Writing
This story doesn't have NSFW content so it's fine to be posted to Creative Writing. Unless you have plans to change it in the future.
Maybe add stuff that in SB would be fade to black, while here you could post the whole scene

As for @Turncoat's comment, Creative Writing has much less traffic than NSFW Creative Writing.
Also even if it is not NSFW it would allow readers to post stuff that wouldn't be appropriate in Creative Writing
As a result a lot of authors just post on NSFW Creative Writing from the beginning. Both to get more readers and to have more freedom.
 
There is Creative Writing and NSFW Creative Writing
This story doesn't have NSFW content so it's fine to be posted to Creative Writing. Unless you have plans to change it in the future.
Maybe add stuff that in SB would be fade to black, while here you could post the whole scene

As for @Turncoat's comment, Creative Writing has much less traffic than NSFW Creative Writing.
Also even if it is not NSFW it would allow readers to post stuff that wouldn't be appropriate in Creative Writing
As a result a lot of authors just post on NSFW Creative Writing from the beginning. Both to get more readers and to have more freedom.
Ohh, thanks for the explanation. I don't write NSFW scenes (... ever) so that's why I thought I shouldn't/wasn't allowed to post in the NSFW thread. Explains the lowered traffic over here compared to SB tho.
 
Oh am I in the wrong section? Should it be in a different forum? Still kinda new to this website, so I'm unsure
As it's been explained by others, you have the gist. The reality is that even if there's never so much as a nipple described, even authors like Failninja, Brosef/SeatAdmiral, Wiererid, and others use nsfw. It's just a much better place for your stories overall.

The division of nsfw and sfw on this site was generally a bad thing.
 
As it's been explained by others, you have the gist. The reality is that even if there's never so much as a nipple described, even authors like Failninja, Brosef/SeatAdmiral, Wiererid, and others use nsfw. It's just a much better place for your stories overall.

The division of nsfw and sfw on this site was generally a bad thing.
Yeah, if you look at the message difference between the two it'll paint a stark picture: 280 thousand vs 8 million. I would suggest messaging the mods and asking for them to move the thread.
 
Well now, I look forward to how will Crawford explain this detail to his minder, or how will he explain the chain of events.

Will he get to trespassing to gather evidence in true Batman fashion?

Edit: regarding the SFW/NSFW divide, I consider a fic matches the NSFW if there's enough graphic and explicit violence to earn the M rating, so it isn't just smut which gets the rating as well.

Mature themes discussed also fit in quite neatly, too.

I do think the SFW section is hampered by self-censorship due to how 'SFW' works, less freedom in that regard.

And most readers here are in for the smut, if not for mature stories that require a degree of maturity that thin-skinned customers from other websites wouldn't appreciate.
 
Last edited:
Well now, I look forward to how will Crawford explain this detail to his minder, or how will he explain the chain of events.

Will he get to trespassing to gather evidence in true Batman fashion?
Honestly with how dogged Dawlish seems to be with these cases, just dropping the book in front of him with the rabbit entry highlighted will probably do the trick. It'll likely cause Dawlish to continue to act evermore like a too stiff prick with a even larger one shoved up his bum, but them the breaks.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top