• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • See here for information on the recent site downtime.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.
I mean...*looks at Berlin By Night, Chaos Factor, MECHA, Haight, Baba Yaga etc.
Strictly speaking, canon lines are a bit zigzag on what they are still and still aren't for 1st and 2nd Edition stuff.

But my point is that thinking SPD is part of the Technocracy is perfectly valid for numerous reasons. You don't have to get so annoyed at it.
Given it hasn't been canon in ages, yes I do have right to feel annoyed over it. You do not get to tell be what I can't be annoyed about.

I didn't insult him over it, I didn't say it wasn't ever canon. Just not mainline canon anymore.

Canonlines are fucking mess yes, but 1e and 2e hasn't been mainline canon or even treat as "this is true" for ages. A lot has been just gone and that is good for a lot of gamelines.
 
So Hunter the Parenting released a new Secret Hunters episode (the ones where Markus and Kitten look for haunted video games). From the looks of it:

1. The next big arc will be probably about mages after the werewolf arc finally ends. Which I am conflicted about, on one hand their Norfolk Wizard Game series shows they know how to handle Mage, on the other hand I really want to go back to the Supernatural Season 1/2 feeling of the early series.

2. They also decided to advertise a new StoryTeller Vault fan-book related to Werewolves. It sounds good but it's 40 USD so I am going to wait for a sale, but if anyone reads it/gets it please share your views.
We still haven't had a follow up to whatever the sabbat may have been planning, the Tremere regent even showing up after her ghoul in the supermarket informed on the crew, the blue creature, etc ad they are moving on to mage?
 
Given it hasn't been canon in ages, yes I do have right to feel annoyed over it. You do not get to tell be what I can't be annoyed about.

I didn't insult him over it, I didn't say it wasn't ever canon. Just not mainline canon anymore.

Canonlines are fucking mess yes, but 1e and 2e hasn't been mainline canon or even treat as "this is true" for ages. A lot has been just gone and that is good for a lot of gamelines.
Even the Technocracy Reloaded still treats SPD as a Syndicate methodology. Hell, I need to correct myself on my previous answer since they apparently STILL receive quarterly taxes from SPD.
21dcd1af0290.png

a0a9746880bf.png
Even the text on M20 is very suspicious. "So, what is the Syndicate putting into this particular black box, considering that they are still getting paid in the name of the SPD?"
I have no right to tell a person what to feel. But I can tell you that it is very easy to think SPD is still a valid part of the Syndicate.

We still haven't had a follow up to whatever the sabbat may have been planning, the Tremere regent even showing up after her ghoul in the supermarket informed on the crew, the blue creature, etc ad they are moving on to mage?
I really got excited thinking we were going to get some more info on the Sabbat side when they were doing the woof audio log and Matilda came across vampires in the Umbra. It was a nothing burger...
Like, I don't hate the werewolf plot but can we go back to the Sabbat, Ghoul and the whole OG storyline for a bit?
 
Last edited:
Even the Technocracy Reloaded still treats SPD as a Syndicate methodology. Hell, I need to correct myself on my previous answer since they apparently STILL receive quarterly taxes from SPD.
21dcd1af0290.png

a0a9746880bf.png
Even the text on M20 is very suspicious. "So, what is the Syndicate putting into this particular black box, considering that they are still getting paid in the name of the SPD?"
I have no right to tell a person what to feel. But I can tell you that it is very easy to think SPD is still a valid part of the Syndicate.
Expect for all the points its not. Its disappeared, and while its paying back like nothing is wrong. It has active agents going "What the fuck is this, we have to look into this and keep this from rest of the Union".

Hell sake, we have active group of the Syndicate hunting and trying to shut them down.
 
Last edited:
The Special Information Security Division is like right there, in the very same book that your pulling from for that. To the POINT its pretending to be the SPD, and even fooled groups like Invictus

Technocracy Reloaded 119 for the info.
 
Last edited:
Expect for all the points its not. Its disappeared, and while its paying back like nothing is wrong. It has active agents going "What the fuck is this, we have to look into this and keep this from rest of the Union".

Hell sake, we have active group of the Syndicate hunting and trying to shut them down.
Yes but for all practical purposes for most Mages, SPD is still part of the Syndicate.
To the point the very group you mention, Project Invictus (which isn't a Syndicate group but explicitly left with unknown origins*), still thinks SPD is part of the Syndicate.
*
42b44c6dee35.png
The very same group who thinks SISD is SPD aka still part of the Syndicate.

So if someone new or isn't a lorenerd goes "SPD is Syndicate", it isn't really strange. That's my point.
The Special Information Security Division is like right there, in the very same book that your pulling from for that. To the POINT its pretending to be the SPD, and even fooled groups like Invictus

Technocracy Reloaded 119 for the info
?
Yes...I posted it on the previous page for Bommel.
In M20, it basically the same but by the modern times, they basically fully left and the few Syndicate who know they left keep the others in the Syndicate and the rest of the Technocracy.
9e6c25aa64f1.png

6824a1e5ffa4.png
considering how Choose Your Own Setting/History oWoD is I don't really care, but it also isn't a fixation for me.
I know I can get absolutely anal about the things that are, so I can't really throw stones :V
I also don't care but I just don't want people new to the setting to get treated aggressively just because of something like this.
 
Yes but for all practical purposes for most Mages, SPD is still part of the Syndicate.

The very same group who thinks SISD is SPD aka still part of the Syndicate.

So if someone new or isn't a lorenerd goes "SPD is Syndicate", it isn't really strange. That's my point.
Then why are you acting like SISD isn't pretending to be SPD which is not the real SPD that left? A faction pretending to be a faction, but not really being something you should clear up. Not leave to be misunderstood.

This isn't about in world info, we are can say what they don't know. I can even understand them not having the books, but you can clear it up.
 
Last edited:
Then why are you acting like SISD isn't pretending to be SPD which is not the real SPD that left? A faction pretending to be a faction, but not really being something you should clear up. Not leave to be misunderstood.

This isn't about in world info, we are can say what they don't know. I can even understand them not having the books, but you can clear it up.
I did clear it up for Bommel after telling you lay off though?

My point isn't whether SPD is or isn't the Syndicate. (Or whether you should have them be Syndicate or not, since M20 by default is meta-agnostic)
My point is that it is a very easy thing to think it is and no need to be so aggressive towards someone because of it, especially if they are new.

That's it.
 
I did clear it up for Bommel after telling you lay off though?

My point isn't whether SPD is or isn't the Syndicate. (Or whether you should have them be Syndicate or not, since M20 by default is meta-agnostic)
My point is that it is a very easy thing to think it is and no need to be so aggressive towards someone because of it, especially if they are new.

That's it.
I wasn't aggressive? I was annoyed. I even suggested a place Bommel could find the books as the stores don't carry them.
 
New alpha is out.
Alpha 2.0: Changing Course
Hello, Kindred! Diogo speaking (actually writing) here, lead game designer at White Wolf. It has been some wild nights since the release of Alpha 1.0. We took Alpha 1.0 in a new direction, deliberately experimenting with rules and approaches that appealed to us, knowing that a lot could change after testing them out. We want to see how far we could push some assumptions, what new things we could get away with, and a lot of you told us it wasn't working yet. You were right about a lot of it, and that's exactly what a playtest is for. Your feedback shaped the Alpha 2.0 you're about to see, and hopefully play.More than 1,000 of you filled out the Alpha 1.0 feedback forms, and many of you went out of your way to encourage the team. Thank you! In DD#3 we told you what we heard. This time, it's what we did about it, and what Alpha 2.0 is testing.You can catch up on our previous Dev Diaries here.
Get Alpha 2.0 on Demiplane, Roll20 or DriveThruRPG!

 
Recently I talked about the Werewolf fan-supplement Alfabusa advertised.

A Werewolf RPG Podcast group called the "Galliard Group" did a review for it.

It was taken down in a day (before I could watch it) by a DMCA strike issued by the authors because apparently the author's got offended (found no concrete information as of writing this post).

I was curious about the book previously, but this killed my interest as regardless of opinions expressed, an author attacking a review because they did not like it is a major red flag for me.
 
That not a good look. Wonder what they said about it

Here is what I gathered kinda. Mind you I did not have a chance to listen to about 5 hours worth of podcast footage to confirm the details or get the full picture

1. Galliard Group talked to some of the authors prior to their review, it was tense/they walked around eggshells (one of the authors did not like that GG kept calling Wendigo well Wendigo - it was renamed in the supplement)

2. Galliard Group published Part 1 (Part 1 was to be lore, part 2 was to be mechanics) of the review a day ago. TL DR They criticised:

- The tribe renaming, the insertion of a new tribe and lore retcons and changes

- The fact that a good chunk of the art (that wasn't reused from W5) was most likely done by a furry porn artist and that it usually involved the OC's/PC's of the authors live play game.

- A ton of format and grammatical errors

- The book focuses on certain modern day politics

3. The video gets DMCA'd by one of the authors for using images from the book and gets taken down, even though other review channels showed more content from the books yet they weren't attacked for it.

4. One of the authors posted the following

5. GG uploaded the sound file of the podcast online, the uploaded the part 2 on another channel (it was co reviewed) that explained the above seen timeline of events before delving into the mechanics
 
Yeah, should stay away from that ST book and authors. Sound toxic as fuck.

Only "The fact that a good chunk of the art (that wasn't reused from W5) was most likely done by a furry porn artist and that it usually involved the OC's/PC's of the authors live play game." point is meh (like, the most WoD thing you can do as an author is putting your PC/OC as a character. Half the writers did so. Plus as someone who frequents QQ, I can't really say anything about furry porn artists), others are huge red flags.
 
@vighzs , @Maragas :

And were Galliard Group transphobic? Not asking about Fascism because of Rule 8.

Reminder that not everyone in QQ sympathizes with adverse stances on trans people.

Edit: Nor do I sympathize; sorry if that makes any of you unreasonably angry.
 
Last edited:
@vighzs , @Maragas :

And were Galliard Group transphobic? Not asking about Fascism because of Rule 8.

Reminder that not everyone in QQ sympathizes with adverse stances on trans people.

Edit: Nor do I sympathize; sorry if that makes any of you unreasonably angry.

They don't sound like they are, from what I've been listening to, they are not upset/phobic about the inclusion of trans people, they are upset because they keep focusing on it as a key aspect of being a werewolf (with the whole changing thing.). Seemingly they mostly dislike turning WtA RP's into ERP's, making the game focused around that instead of punching things in the face.

Can't 100% confirm it though as I neither read the book or listened to podcast 1 (did not have time to download it or listen to it yet).

The second part I can debunk as at least one member of the podcast is jewish
 
They don't sound like they are, from what I've been listening to, they are not upset/phobic about the inclusion of trans people, they are upset because they keep focusing on it as a key aspect of being a werewolf (with the whole changing thing.). Seemingly they mostly dislike turning WtA RP's into ERP's, making the game focused around that instead of punching things in the face.

Can't 100% confirm it though as I neither read the book or listened to podcast 1 (did not have time to download it or listen to it yet).

The second part I can debunk as at least one member of the podcast is jewish

Ah; from what I've heard (am not really a fan of anything WtA, whether OG WtA or W5 because of the Ecoterrorism and the hard flip-flopping to supporting peaceful, nonviolent activism despite being a flipping' Werewolf), Werewolf the Essentials is supposed to be about having more conflict, not less, with many of the changes in the lore supposed to be about causing more conflict, not less.

And the 'new tribe' are Kinfolk and Metis/Crinos-born (Metis never really made sense for the child of two Werewolves because Metis refers to mixed-race folk IRL, not inbreds) who combined together for more rights, aka the Hearthbound. How is that only ERP-fodder instead of a conflict seed?

@ghost armor 1337 is a fan of Werewolf the Essentials. Perhaps he can shed more light on this?
 
Last edited:
Ah; from what I've heard (am not really a fan of anything WtA, whether OG WtA or W5 because of the Ecoterrorism and the hard flip-flopping to supporting peaceful, nonviolent activism despite being a flipping' Werewolf), Werewolf the Essentials is supposed to be about having more conflict, not less, with many of the changes in the lore supposed to be about causing more conflict, not less.

And the 'new tribe' are Kinfolk and Metis/Crinos-born (Metis never really made sense for the child of two Werewolves because Metis refers to mixed-race folk IRL, not inbreds) who combined together for more rights, aka the Hearthbound. How is that only ERP-fodder instead of a conflict seed?

@ghost armor 1337 is a fan of Werewolf the Essentials. Perhaps he can shed more light on this?

They are against mixing ERP into their WtA/WoD Chronicles in general from what I know, apologies if I worded it in an incorrect manner. And thank you for pinging someone who might know more.

The reason I started talking about this was as mentioned above, because it's a major red flag for me when an author attacks a review, not becasue it's plagiarism (as also mentioned other reviews showed far more content from the book supposedly) but because they do not like the contents of the review.

Behaviour like that rubs me the wrong way and since this fan-supplement was even advertised by Alfabusa I wanted to let people know as that information might be important prior to purchase, especially since it's roughly 40 eur.
 
Behaviour like that rubs me the wrong way and since this fan-supplement was even advertised by Alfabusa I wanted to let people know as that information might be important prior to purchase, especially since it's roughly 40 eur.
iirc they say in the video that alfabusa worked on the book
 
iirc they say in the video that alfabusa worked on the book
Which, to me, is a massive red flag in and of itself. Alfabusa, and that whole creator group are, in the times I've interacted with them outside their scripted works, massive egotistical douchebags and cowards. Say what you will about their shows, I've enjoyed them, but the creators are just nasty, petty people with no honour.

Also, correct me if I'm misremembering, but did Alfabusa state his affiliation with this product he's shilling in his ad for it? Because if not, I'm fairly certain that qualifies as fraud.
 
Last edited:
been listening to the episode with quarter of an ear while making food and doing stuff, most that's kind of stuck been bitching about the racism/stereotyping, something about treating different tribes as if they were same/similar, didn't like fianna and compared it to a hypothetical british tribe named avalon being renamed a circle of swords or something.

oh, and they did talk about trans stuff at the beginning, the group's thoughts on it was something along the lines of "yeah first change can work as metaphor for your egg cracking, everyone can see that, but your execution was shit." and the book being created for first time STs running trans games or something according to a/the creator.

also the lore changes are based on the lore of the creators' home game.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Back
    Top