• A notice about Rule 3 regarding sites hosting pirated/unauthorized content has been made. Please see here for details.
  • Staff is working to deal with the problem of synonymous tags. See here for more information and to suggest tag mergers.
  • Due to issues with external spam filters, QQ is currently unable to send any mail to Microsoft E-mail addresses. This includes any account at live.com, hotmail.com or msn.com. Signing up to the forum with one of these addresses will result in your verification E-mail never arriving. For best results, please use a different E-mail provider for your QQ address.
  • For prospective new members, a word of warning: don't use common names like Dennis, Simon, or Kenny if you decide to create an account. Spammers have used them all before you and gotten those names flagged in the anti-spam databases. Your account registration will be rejected because of it.
  • Since it has happened MULTIPLE times now, I want to be very clear about this. You do not get to abandon an account and create a new one. You do not get to pass an account to someone else and create a new one. If you do so anyway, you will be banned for creating sockpuppets.
  • Due to the actions of particularly persistent spammers and trolls, we will be banning disposable email addresses from today onward.

On a Pale Horse (Umamusume/Youjo Senki)

Also it's been noted that once he was being taken on a walk and he came across a pasture with some ponies and he got excited, apparently from seeing some horses the same size as him.
"See, I'm not really the tiniest!"

Poor Stay Gold, having to deal with mares that didn't like him because he was too small.

Though that shouldn't be as much of a problem for uma Stay Gold.

But yeah, horse Stay Gold and horse Shirogane would probably be considered a less promising pairing, the hope would probably be that a foal would have Stay Gold's speed and Shirogane's stamina, and that Shirogane's more reserved temperament would even out Stay Gold's unruly nature. This later hope would be in vain, most likely, unless the foal was allowed to stay with Shirogane for some time (which usually doesn't happen with broodmares).

Truly, she shall be The Demon of Distance.
"Dangerous past 2 kilometers, Deadly past 3"

I love Tanya crossovers, but this one feels unique by starting off as a nice slice of life and then swapping into a sports drama, and overall this feels like Tanya basically died in life 2 and went to heaven.
Shirogane isn't a Tanya-esque figure desperate to prove something; she is someone living the dream of a peaceful, stable life. As many have already noted, she is essentially a "grandma in a young girl's body."
Shiro is basically a Tanya that has basically secured her cushy retirement, so she doesn't really feel the need to scrabble for strength or influence like Tanya's are often betrayed. Tanya as a character is certainly not conflict averse or unwilling to risk themself, and they aren't the type to be happy being idle, but they also aren;t strongly inclined to take the risky options if they aren't convinced that maintaining their position depends on it.

El Condor Pasa, a very powerful racer of her generation clearly had to substantially push herself to win this race and she still just barely managed it.
Shirogane is kinda like those spinning gates designed to push horses to walk in a circle, as she gradually gets a bit faster she pushes her classmates to go faster as well.

The issue in my mind is that Shiro is written and treated as a Sword of Damocles.
But isn't that exactly what a sword of damocles is? That discomfort to other umas, that consistency, it's an implied threat that any mistake will lead to the other racers downfall.
Err...not really? Shiro isn't some enforcer waiting for them to slip up so she can kick them out of school or something. While she can theoretically beat them up if she had reason to, her propensity for violence isn't very obvious to most of the classmates who grew up in safe environments. The Sword of Damocles is a very obvious threat that the person under it specifically is aware of. Shirogane's propensity for violence is more of a Chekov's gun situation.

As far as her rivals are concerned, Shirogane represents more an example of how the rivals you start out able to beat fairly easily can get stronger, so you shouldn't get complacent. None of them are worried that she will cause them serious harm.

I hope you don't take my speal of criticisms negatively
I appreciate good faith criticism. I can see how the story is moving rather slowly, but it will be picking up a bit starting from the next chapter or so, as the Classic Year really starts to kick off.

And this is without winning any graded races so far too.

where is El Condor Pasa?
Running the Spring Stakes, probably.

El Condor Pasa and Grass Wonder have the issue where their umaverse career path has them running some races they didn't run irl, since both have the Tokyo Yushun on it while not the Satsuki Sho, which I'm working off of to say what they would do in the more idealized uma world where they weren't banned from competing in the Triple Crown because they are foreigners.

This is funny because it shows that Shirogane really doesn't follow the racing industry, and has no idea what "normal" is
She's also working off the assumption that to go into both circuits she'd have to clinch a berth in both otherwise they would not put her in the other circuit despite her high prize total.

I feel like it'd be cool to see an Umaverse netkeiba omake, where various users are discussing the ongoing careers of the Golden Gen
The trainers at a bar scene could be funny, especially if they are all slightly tipsy.

"Where did you find this crazy girl, Hana?"

"On a bridge."

Hot damn, 175.85 million yen? Is that before or after Tracen and the government takes their share?
Before, so in reality her take home amount is quite a bit less. Still a lot of money for her age, and fortunately she's actually one to use it more responsibly.

… hey do you think Shiro would become a trainer if she didn't had her family restaurant to think about?
It would not be her first thought. She might have ended up on Tracen's security team as a dual student/security trainee.

Mercy be upon any junior that Shiro thinks she needs to be A Good Senpai for. Because the silver eagle has none.
There's a couple umas who I think might respond fairly well to this, with Symboli Kris S and Eishin Flash coming to mind.

Here, Shiro sees her parents as the boss and instinctively has to support them by helping in the restaurant or studying even from a young age. Not being able to support them actively causes her to be depressed. She's very much a workhorse like that. She has to work instinctively and not working is actually a form of torture to her.
That's basically what was going on with young Shiro, which isn't something too unusual for young umas, but her family really did not expect this to apply to homework.

It's also one of the ironies of her character, in that while she wants to have this peaceful life, her need to be useful means that she would not enjoy a life of pure relaxation.
 
I thought that Shiro gave the impression that she'd use the sword she carries on the uma in front of her in a race? Or was that only that one skittish uma?

Hmm. Shiro knows how to use that sword from officer training, right? I wonder if she learned any showy sword forms? Or if she'd be willing to learn any? A sword dance counts as a dance, right? =)

Would Shiro be doing sword drills to "get back in shape" since she (sometimes) carries a sword? Might be something scary for the other uma to see her doing.
 
Given how often Shirogane would show up in other umas' careers, she'd probably become something like the Majima meme or a Wit check.
I have this amusing idea where Shirogane is blue character in the game and she shows up at least once in every 10 pull the moment she's released.
Or a bit like Machan where you can just see her practicing on the track, the streets or the background in other uma's careers.
 
horse Stay Gold and horse Shirogane
Gold Falcon was an indomnitable monster and that was the problem. He got banned from the Japanese racing League for his behavior but found unexpected popularity abroad.

His little sister Electrum on the other hand was raised by Shirogane and took after her. An even faster Shirogane. Nicknamed the Massacre Pony because all she left behind was a mass grave of her opponent's hopes and dreams their only solace is that unlike her mother, Electrum seldom raced for more than the bare requirement necessary to qualify for bigger race.
 
I was looking at G1 races Shirogane could probably shine in before the Kikuka Sho, Arima Kinen, Tenno Sho Spring, and came across the Japan Dirt Derby(now the Japan Dirt Classic) which is a 2000m G1 race on dirt that happens in Early July, but it doesn't exist yet until next year 1999. Also now that we know she isn't really affected by track conditions and can run on any surface she might do well in the Prix during her 3rd year assuming she locks in at that point in her career.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top